- EN English
Machine translations can contain errors potentially reducing clarity and accuracy; the Ombudsman accepts no liability for any discrepancies. For the most reliable information and legal certainty, please refer to the source version in French linked above.
For more information please consult our language and translation policy.
Monitor the effects of lobbying on decision-making and good administration
Speech - Speaker Teresa Anjinho - City Strasbourg - Country France - Date Thursday | 19 November 2026
Speech by Ombudsman Teresa Anjinho at the Grand Conference ‘Decision-making in the European Union: Borders of influence’
Dear Jérôme Filippini, Director of the National Institute of Public Service,
Dear Frédérique Berrod, President of the University of Strasbourg,
Dear Nathalie Rubio, Chair of the GIS/Eurolab Steering Committee,
Dear Ségolène Barbou des Places, Chair of the GIS/Eurolab Steering Committee,
Dear teachers and students,
Good evening to everyone. It is a pleasure to be in Strasbourg – a city that has made reconciliation and the crossing of borders a reality– to speak specifically of borders: those of influence.
I would like to thank Director Filippini and the National Institute of Public Service for their kind invitation to participate in this Grand Conference. Many of you will soon be on the other side of the table. You will receive emails, attend meetings, and read position papers.
Tonight, I do not want to talk about lobbying in an abstract way, but about a question that you will face almost daily in your professional life: who influences the decision I have to make – and is the public informed about it?
As European Ombudsman, I look at ‘how’ decisions are taken at EU level – whether the correct rules and procedures have been followed. But I also look at ‘who’ is involved: all those people outside the administration whose contributions have shaped or attempted to shape EU laws and policies.
Tonight, I will do three things: explain why lobbying is important and where it becomes an undue influence; share what my office has learned from its investigations; and look to the future to identify the challenges that will define your careers.
Let me be clear from the outset: lobbying is not a bad word. Well-regulated and transparent lobbying can provide citizens, businesses and civil society with an effective voice. It provides policymakers with invaluable expertise and data. Otherwise, the decision-making process would be less robust and less rich.
But lobbying is never neutral, because access is not equally distributed. Those with greater resources or better connections usually have greater access to decision makers. This imbalance can lead to a decision-making process in which some interests weigh more than others, even though the latter are just as legitimate, but less well represented.
Undue influence rarely resembles corruption. More often, it resembles a door that opens more easily for some than for others, or an expert whose advice is not entirely disinterested.
This is why the relationship between the public and private sectors must be based on clear rules and a strong culture of ethics and transparency.
Lobbyists also have obligations. But my mandate concerns the administration: through complaints and investigations on my own initiative, I examine whether the administration’s interactions with interest representatives are appropriate, transparent and ethical.
The EU administration generally applies high standards and is composed of conscientious officials, committed to the common good. But no system is perfect. Gaps appear; expectations are changing. This is where surveillance finds its place.
Rather than presenting you with a catalogue of cases, let me share four lessons.
First: the effectiveness of a transparency scheme depends above all on the rigour with which it is applied.
The EU Transparency Register allows citizens to see who is seeking to influence decision-making in the EU. In an investigation, we found that complaints about the lack of transparency of certain organisations regarding their links with industry and their sources of funding had been addressed too narrowly.
Following our intervention, the Registry Secretariat acknowledged the problem and undertook to update its guidelines.
A register that is not verified remains a simple list; it is not a real guarantee of transparency.
Second: those seeking to influence a policy should not be remunerated to provide advice on that same policy.
We looked at a case in which a study on a regulatory issue had been attributed to a company with a direct commercial interest in the same issue – and a history of lobbying on it. Our suggestions led the Commission to amend its procurement guidelines, and EU financial rules now exclude bidders with such professional conflicts of interest.
Third, hospitality can also be a form of influence.
After a business trip of a senior official was paid for by third parties, we examined how such offers are evaluated. The Commission has tightened its rules and now records - directly in the tool used by staff to plan their travels - who pays for staff missions, what the cost is, and how possible conflicts of interest have been assessed.
Fourth: revolving doors, a transition from the public to the private sector, must follow clear rules.
Few things undermine citizens’ trust more than a senior official joining a company he was previously in charge of regulating.
Everyone has the right to work and to change careers – but this right must be reconciled with the need to maintain trust in public institutions.
We cannot take the risk that citizens see public decision-making either as an open process and at the service of all, but as a closed system, in which the same actors find themselves on both sides of the table.
There has been real progress, but standards still vary across EU bodies.
My recent survey of EU agencies – which shape policies in areas ranging from chemicals and medicines to banking and defence – highlighted robust policies, but also gaps and inconsistencies in training, transparency and implementation of corrective actions.
We have therefore developed good practice guidelines, drawing heavily on what the agencies were already doing well themselves.
Because often the solution already exists within the administration. Our role is to make it the rule rather than the exception.
Ladies and gentlemen,
I believe that the future of good administration is based on three key principles.
First, transparency – who has influence, what and how.
Today, not only who asked for a meeting, but what was discussed, what was exchanged, and what are the channels through which influence is exercised. This should include new and informal forms of interaction.
We are currently examining a consultation practice in which selected stakeholders are invited to share their practical experience of EU rules, outside the transparency rules that apply to regular lobbying meetings.
The question is simple: when does information gathering become a way of influencing policy-making?
Transparency must ensure the visibility of each step of the decision-making process, regardless of the form or format of the exchanges.
Second, integrity – defending the public interest.
Rules can define the line we need to follow, but it is integrity that tells us how to follow it.
Beyond increased mobility between the public and private sectors, decision-making processes are also becoming more complex. There is an increasing need for external expertise in the institutions. But this expertise must never become a vehicle for undue influence.
We examine, for example, whether possible conflicts of interest have been duly taken into account in appointments to high-level advisory functions in the field of new technologies. The more we depend on expertise, the more we need to know who it comes from and what its interests are.
And finally, accountability – accountability and independent and effective oversight.
The rules, without effective control mechanisms, risk remaining mere promises. Ombudsmen, auditors, ethics bodies, the press, civil society and citizens themselves need to be able to ask questions and get answers.
Accountability does not reflect mistrust of the administration; on the contrary, it is an essential condition for the trust that citizens can place in it.
These three principles are now being tested by the digital transformation.
For a long time, we asked: Who is sitting at the table? This question remains essential – but it is no longer enough.
Today, we must also ask: how was the tool that summarised the results of the consultation designed? How was the model that produced the first draft developed? How can we ensure transparency regardless of the format of the consultation?
Artificial intelligence also amplifies an ancient phenomenon: ‘astroturfing’ – campaigns that give the impression of emanating from spontaneous popular mobilisation.
In a matter of minutes, AI can generate thousands of contributions to a public consultation, with varied wording and seemingly authentic tone.
Those who were already in the spotlight now have an even more powerful megaphone.
The risk is twofold: that the institutions confuse fabricated opinion with genuine public support – and, even more serious, that citizens’ speech is stifled or wrongly considered artificial.
This obliges us to extend the scope of transparency: not only to individuals but also to processes. We need to know not only who was heard, but how the contributions were collected, filtered and weighted – and what tools were involved in drafting the rules that govern us all.
In other words, the digital transformation does not diminish our demand for transparency: it makes it even more necessary
Ladies and gentlemen,
I started by saying that lobbying is a double-edged sword. It is an integral part of participatory democracy – but when diverted from its purpose, it can threaten the fairness and impartiality of the decision-making process.
On which side will the scale be tilted? It depends on the strength of the rules and their compliance, the mechanisms to control our ability to anticipate new challenges.
But, above all, it depends on the people. Of each of you.
Whether we are a public official or a lobbyist, we must ask ourselves not only "is it legal?" but also "is it legitimate?" and "is it right?"
Citizens will rarely see the meetings you accept or the projects you receive. They will only see the outcome – and they will judge Europe by it.
Their trust is not acquired once and for all; it is won, decision after decision.
Tomorrow you will have a special responsibility: to transform the rules and principles you learn today into everyday practices.
We are all guardians of this trust.
And this is perhaps the key message I would like to leave you tonight: good administration is measured not only by the quality of the decisions it takes, but also by the way it takes them.
Our actions today will determine the health of our democracy tomorrow.
Thank you and look forward to answering your questions.