FOR PREVIEWING & TESTING PURPOSES ONLY.
This notification will disappear once the page will be published.
This link is available for less than 30 minutes.
  • Easy to read
  • Text size

You have a complaint against an EU institution or body?

Current language: 
  • English
Available languages: 

Draft recommendation of the European Ombudsman in his own-initiative inquiry OI/8/2010/(VIK)CK concerning the European Anti-Fraud Office ('OLAF')

Made in accordance with Article 3(6) of the Statute of the European Ombudsman[1]

The background to the complaint

1. The complaint, submitted by an NGO based in a third country and its Executive Director ("the complainants"), concerns an external investigation carried out by the European Anti-Fraud Office ('OLAF') into alleged fraud by the NGO and its Executive Director.

2. In 1998 and 2001, the complainants signed two contracts with the Commission for the implementation of two EU projects. On 16 August 2006, after receiving information from an informant, OLAF opened an investigation into alleged double funding of the projects, alleged money laundering and alleged misappropriation of funds by the complainants. In the context of its investigation, OLAF carried out, on 6 and 7 February 2008, an on-the-spot-check at the premises of the NGO, in Country X.

3. On 29 October 2008, OLAF closed its investigation. It transmitted its findings to the competent services of the Commission, as well as to the judicial authorities of Country X.

4. In April 2009, the Commission issued a recovery order for the entire amount it had paid for one of the two projects, on the grounds that the project audit reports submitted by the complainants to justify the expenditure under the project had been forged. The complainants did not challenge the recovery order.

5. On 21 January 2010, the complainants made a request to OLAF for access to the Final Case Report of the investigation.

6. On 24 February 2010, OLAF informed the complainants that it had handled their request for access under Regulation (EC) No 1049/2001 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 30 May 2001 regarding public access to European Parliament, Council and Commission documents ("Regulation 1049/2001")[2]. OLAF rejected their request, considering that the document was covered by four exceptions: (i) the protection of privacy and integrity of individuals; (ii) the protection of commercial interests; (iii) the protection of the purposes of inspections, investigations and audits; and (iv) the protection of the Commission’s decision-making process before a decision has been taken. OLAF also informed the complainants that they could submit a confirmatory application against its decision not to disclose the report.

7. By letter of 10 March 2010, the complainants invited OLAF to reconsider its decision not to disclose the report.

8. On 15 June 2010, OLAF confirmed its decision not to disclose the requested document.

9. In the meantime, the complainants turned to the European Ombudsman with a number of allegations in relation to the way OLAF had conducted its investigation and its refusal to disclose its Final Case Report. The Ombudsman declared the complaint inadmissible on the basis of Article 228 TFEU, as it had not been submitted by authorised complainants. Nevertheless, in light of the seriousness of the issues raised, the Ombudsman opened an own-initiative inquiry into the case.

The subject matter of the inquiry

10. The own-initiative inquiry covers the following allegations and claims:

Allegations:

(1) OLAF committed a breach of confidentiality and failed to respect professional secrecy by disclosing information about the complainants to the national authorities of Country X, to the media and to other improper recipients.

(2) OLAF wrongly failed to grant the complainants access to its final report.

(3) OLAF failed to respect the complainants' presumption of innocence, the rights of defence and the principle of fairness in the investigation it carried out.

Claims:

(1) OLAF should offer the complainants an apology.

(2) OLAF should grant the complainants access to the documents requested.

(3) OLAF should provide financial compensation to the complainants for the damage caused.

The inquiry

11. On 22 June 2010, the Ombudsman opened an inquiry and asked OLAF to provide an opinion on the allegations and claims set out above.

12. On 22 September 2010, the Ombudsman received OLAF's opinion, which he forwarded to the complainants with an invitation to make observations. The Ombudsman received the complainants' observations on 29 October 2010.

13. On 25 and 26 June 2011, the Ombudsman's services carried out an inspection of OLAF's file concerning the present case. The inspection took place at OLAF's premises in Brussels. On 5 September 2011, the Ombudsman sent to OLAF and to the complainants a copy of his report on the inspection. On 23 September 2011, the Ombudsman received comments from the complainants on the above-mentioned report.

The Ombudsman's analysis and conclusions

Preliminary remarks

14. The present Draft Recommendation only deals with the allegation of the refusal to give access to the Final Case Report. In light of OLAF's response to the present Draft Recommendation and of the complainant's observations, the Ombudsman will, at a later stage of his inquiry, deal with the arguments put forward by the complainants and OLAF in relation to the two other allegations and claims.

A. Alleged unjustified refusal to disclose the requested document and related claim

Arguments presented to the Ombudsman

15. In its opinion, OLAF stated that access to the Final Case Report should be refused for the reasons that it had already put forward in its letter to the complainants dated 15 June 2010. OLAF explained to the complainants that their requests for access to documents had been dealt with under Regulation 1049/2011, as the interested parties have no specific right of direct access to the OLAF investigation file. It added that the interested parties have a right of access under the same terms and conditions as any other natural or legal person[3] and that, when dealing with public access requests, OLAF needs to take into account that any document it discloses would enter the public domain. Next, OLAF confirmed its decision not to disclose the requested document. It explained that the Final Case Report was covered by four exceptions provided for by Regulation 1049/2001.

16. First, OLAF invoked the exception related to the purpose of inspections, investigations and audits, as set out in Article 4 (2), third indent. In particular, OLAF stated that the requested document contains OLAF findings regarding OLAF investigative activities, possible mismanagement of EU funds and forgery of documents. It expressed the view that, since the relevant information had been transmitted to the Commission and the judicial authorities of Country X, disclosure of the document would jeopardise the outcome of various follow-up proceedings. In addition, disclosure would reveal what kind of evidence had been gathered from different sources. In this regard, OLAF referred to the Franchet and Byk judgment, where the Court considered that disclosure of documents that could constitute evidence in national court proceedings could compromise the effective use of this evidence by the national authorities[4].

17. Second, OLAF referred to the protection of the Commission's decision-making process in a matter where the decision has not yet been adopted (Article 4(3), first paragraph). According to OLAF, disclosure of the requested document could jeopardise the outcome of the ongoing recovery procedure, by exposing the Commission and its services to possible external interference and thus preventing it from adopting a final decision free from external influence.

18. Third, OLAF invoked the protection of privacy and integrity of individuals (Article 4(1)(b)). It argued that the requested document contains the personal data of individuals, such as officials of the national authorities, as well as employees of private companies and of NGOs, the disclosure of which would affect their privacy.

19. Fourth, OLAF put forward the exception related to the protection of commercial interests (Article 4(2), first indent). It stated that the requested document contains information that would harm the reputation of legal entities before a final decision is taken by national authorities.

20. Finally, OLAF noted that the above exceptions covered the documents to such an extent that the rest of the text would have been deprived of substance and would, therefore, have been meaningless. It thus concluded that partial access was not possible.

21. The complainants stated that OLAF failed to demonstrate how the exceptions that it had relied upon apply to the requested document. In relation to the first exception, they argued that OLAF did not demonstrate how disclosure of the Final Case Report would impede the completion of inspections, investigations or audits, since it was clear that there were no ongoing investigations. They stated that it was clear from the information submitted by OLAF that the investigations had been completed and that the Commission had initiated recovery proceedings.

22. Regarding the second exception, the complainants argued that OLAF simply asserted that disclosure of the Final Case Report would jeopardise the outcome of the proceedings initiated by the European Commission without, however, specifying to what kind of external interference OLAF referred. In their views, it was not clear how disclosure of the Final Case Report would lead to interference, given that the Commission had already initiated recovery proceedings.

23. In relation to the third and fourth exceptions, the complainants noted that the interests of natural and legal persons could be protected by simply removing their names. In their view, OLAF did not provide adequate justification as to why it could not provide them with a redacted version of the requested document.

The Ombudsman's assessment

24. At the outset, the Ombudsman notes that, in this particular case, he will not take a stance regarding OLAF's position that the interested parties have no specific right of direct access to the OLAF investigation file. He will not, therefore, examine whether OLAF should have assessed the complainants' request under a different legal framework. He will only examine whether OLAF correctly applied Regulation 1049/2001.

25. Regulation 1049/2001 reflects the intention of creating an ever closer union among the peoples of Europe, in which decisions are taken as openly and as closely as possible to the citizen. To ensure that this goal is attained, it grants the public a right of access to documents held by the institutions in all areas of activity of the European Union. This right is subject to certain exceptions that are based on the need to protect defined objective public and private interests. The right of public access to documents held by the institutions enhances the democratic nature of the EU institutions[5].

26. According to settled case-law of the Union courts, the exceptions to public access to documents must be interpreted and applied strictly so as not to frustrate the application of the general principle that the public should be given the widest possible access to documents held by the institutions[6]. Furthermore, the examination required for processing a request for access to documents must be specific in nature. First, the mere fact that a document concerns an interest protected by an exception is not sufficient to justify the application of that exception[7]. In principle, the application of an exception can be justified only if the institution has previously determined that access to the document would specifically and actually undermine the protected interest. In addition, the risk that the protected interest may be undermined must be reasonably foreseeable and not purely hypothetical[8]. The examination of the above factors must be apparent from the reasoning of the decision[9].

27. In the present case, the Ombudsman has to examine whether OLAF was entitled to refuse access to the Final Case Report. In order to justify its decision not to grant the complainants access to the requested document, OLAF put forward four grounds. For the reasons explained in detail in the following paragraphs, the Ombudsman considers that two of the grounds are not validly invoked, whereas the remaining two could justify partial disclosure.

(a) Protection of the purpose of investigations

28. The Ombudsman notes that according to the case-law, the exception here concerned, which aims to protect ‘the purpose of inspections, investigations and audits’, applies only if disclosure of the requested document (a) may endanger the completion of those activities or (b) could jeopardise inspections or investigations which are being conducted, for a reasonable period, on the basis of its content[10]. In other words, the exception related to the purposes of inspections, investigations and audits cannot, in principle, be validly invoked when (i) the investigation has essentially ended (for instance, by the issuance of a 'final report'), and (ii) the various authorities (EU and/or national ones) are merely in the process of deciding on follow-up action[11].

29. In the present case, OLAF completed its investigation in October 2008 by drafting a final report and transmitting the relevant information to the Commission and the judicial authorities of Country X. At the time the complainants sought access, there was, therefore, no longer an ongoing investigation by OLAF into the case. It remains to be seen whether other or additional investigations were being carried out, the completion of which would have been endangered through disclosure of the document requested by the complainants in the present case. In this respect, the Ombudsman notes that OLAF transmitted its report to both the Commission and the judicial authorities of Country X. He should therefore examine if disclosure of the requested document could have jeopardised ongoing investigations by these authorities.

30. Regarding the Commission, the Ombudsman notes that, by the time the complainants requested access to the Final Case Report, in January 2010, the Commission had already decided to initiate recovery proceedings. In particular, it had already issued a recovery order in March 2009, the legality of which was never challenged by the complainants. It is clear therefore that any additional investigation that the Commission might have carried out on the basis of the Final Case Report should have been completed before it issued its recovery order.

31. Regarding the existence of ongoing investigations in Country X, the Ombudsman notes that OLAF did not refer to any specific investigation or judicial proceedings which were ongoing at the time of its decision and which might have constituted follow-up action to its Final Case Report. It merely stated that public disclosure of the report would "not enable the judicial authorities in Country X to decide on the follow-up". However, that explanation is rather vague and abstract and does not provide sufficiently concrete information on whether relevant investigations were indeed conducted at the national level and whether the release of the requested document could, specifically and actually, undermine these investigations.

32. Furthermore, the Ombudsman stresses that, according to the case-law, an important element to be taken into consideration in relation to follow-up or additional investigations, inspections and audits is whether these activities are being carried out "within a reasonable period[12]". As the Court stated in Franchet and Byk, "to allow that the various documents relating to inspections, investigations or audits are covered by the exception referred to in the third indent of Article 4(2) of Regulation No 1049/2001 until the follow-up action to be taken has been decided would make access to the IAS documents dependent on an uncertain, future and possibly distant event, depending on the speed and diligence of the various authorities"[13].

33. In the present case, the information submitted to the Ombudsman does not show that the authorities of Country X, which have been in possession of the Final Case Report since October 2008, have undertaken any kind of follow-up action with a view to further investigating the matter or to initiating judicial proceedings. In the Ombudsman's view, the requested document cannot be covered by the invoked exception for an indefinite period of time, during which OLAF simply makes an assumption that there might be follow-up action by the national authorities[14]. Indeed, the Ombudsman considers that, if OLAF wished to apply Article 4(2), third indent, of Regulation 1049/2001 to a request for public access made in 2010, almost two years after it had sent its Final Case Report to Country X, it should have inquired with Country X to determine whether a national investigation was ongoing or was likely to be commenced. OLAF did not do so. In light of the above, the Ombudsman does not consider OLAF's explanations to be convincing.

(b) Protection of the Commission's decision-making process

34. With reference to the second exception relied upon by OLAF, the Ombudsman finds OLAF's explanations vague and abstract, as they do not provide sufficiently concrete information on how the release of the document could seriously undermine the Commission's decision-making process. In any event, as the Ombudsman has already pointed out, the Commission's decision-making process regarding the decision to recover the amount paid to the complainants had ended when the request for public access was made (the Commission had, at that stage, already decided to issue recovery orders). While it is true that, during the recovery proceedings, the Commission could decide to waive recovery or change the amount to be recovered, such action concerns rather the execution and implementation of the recovery order and does not constitute part of the decision-making process relating to the OLAF Final Case Report[15]. The Ombudsman cannot see what other follow-up action the Commission could decide to take in relation to OLAF's Final Case Report. He does not therefore find convincing OLAF's explanation concerning the protection of the Commission's decision-making process.

(c) Protection of personal data
and
(d) Protection of commercial interests

35. OLAF argued that the disclosure of the Final Case Report could affect the privacy of individuals whose personal data are contained in it, as well as the reputation of legal entities before a final decision is taken by national authorities.

36. The Ombudsman considers that OLAF's explanation in this regard is not, in itself, unconvincing. On the basis of the results of the Ombudsman's inspection of OLAF's file, it is clear that these risks exist in the present case, in particular, with respect to the identity of the informant whose information led OLAF to investigate the matter. The Ombudsman therefore finds that OLAF was entitled to invoke the exception set out in Article 4(1)(b) in order to justify its refusal to grant access to the parts of the document that would have allowed the informant to be identified. The same applies to the possible harm to the reputation of the individuals and the legal entities involved. In the context of investigations concerning financial irregularities, this consideration appears, in principle, to be valid.

37. Nevertheless, the Ombudsman cannot overlook the fact that the relevant interests could be protected, even in the event of partial disclosure, by simply blanking out the names of the individuals and legal entities concerned. In this respect, the Ombudsman notes that, in their observations, the complainants referred to the possibility of receiving a redacted version of the requested document. The Ombudsman cannot, therefore, accept OLAF's view that partial access was not possible.

38. In light of the above findings, the Ombudsman considers that OLAF failed to respond adequately to the complainants' request for access to the Final Case Report, and that this constituted an instance of maladministration. He therefore makes a corresponding draft recommendation below, in accordance with Article 3(6) of the Statute of the European Ombudsman.

B. The draft recommendation

On the basis of his inquiries, the Ombudsman makes the following draft recommendation to OLAF:

OLAF should specify and substantiate its reasons for refusing to provide partial access to the Final Case Report. In case there are no such reasons, OLAF should consider the possibility of providing partial access to the requested document by blanking out the names of the individuals and legal entities concerned.

OLAF and the complainants will be informed of this draft recommendation. In accordance with Article 3(6) of the Statute of the European Ombudsman, OLAF shall send a detailed opinion by 31 July 2013. The detailed opinion could consist of the acceptance of the draft recommendation and a description of how it has been implemented.

 

P. Nikiforos Diamandouros

Done in Strasbourg on 5 April 2013

 


[1] Decision of the European Parliament of 9 March 1994 on the regulations and general conditions governing the performance of the Ombudsman's duties (94/262/ECSC, EC, Euratom), OJ 1994 L 113, p. 15.

[2] Regulation (EC) No 1049/2001 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 30 May 2001 regarding public access to European Parliament, Council and Commission documents, OJ 2001 L145, p. 43.

[3] In this respect, OLAF referred to Case T-48/05 Franchet and Byk v Commission [2008] ECR II-01585, paragraphs 255-258.

[4] Joined Cases T-391/03 and T-70/04 Franchet and Byk v Commission, [2006] ECR-II-2023, paragraphs 121-125.

[5] Decision of the European Ombudsman closing his inquiry into complaint 2914/2009/DK against the European Medicines Agency, paragraph 26.

[6] Case C-64/05 P Sweden v Commission [2007] ECR I-11389, paragraph 66; Joined Cases C-39/05 P and C-52/05 P Sweden and Turco v Council [2008] ECR I-4723, paragraph 36; and Franchet and Byk v Commission, cited above, paragraph 84.

[7] Case T-20/99 Denkavit Nederland v Commission [2000] ECR II-3011, paragraph 45.

[8] Case T-211/00 Kuijer v Council [2002] ECR II-485, paragraph 56.

[9] Case T-2/03 Verein für Konsumenteninformation v Commission [2005] ECR II-1121, paragraph 69, and Joined Cases T-391/03 and T-70/04 Franchet and Byk v Commission, cited above, paragraph 115.

[10] Case T-471/08 Toland v Parliament [2011] ECR II-2717, paragraphs 45-58.

[11] Decision of the European Ombudsman closing his inquiry into complaint 943/2007/PB against the European Anti-Fraud Office, paragraph 27.

[12] Joined Cases T-391/03 and T-70/04 Franchet and Byk v Commission, cited above, paragraph 113.

[13] Idem, paragraph 111.

[14] See, also, Case T-123/99 JT’s Corporation v Commission [2000] ECR II-3269, paragraph 50.

[15] Decision of the European Ombudsman closing his inquiry into complaint 876/2011/RT against the European Anti-Fraud Office, paragraph 56.