FOR PREVIEWING & TESTING PURPOSES ONLY.
This notification will disappear once the page will be published.
This link is available for less than 30 minutes.
  • Easy to read
  • Text size

You have a complaint against an EU institution or body?

Current language: 
  • English
Available languages: 

Maintaining the independence of ombudsman institutions

Keynote speech by European Ombudswoman Teresa Anjinho to the roundtable discussion on ombudsman institutions under threat during the Regional Conference in Nicosia, Cyprus

Dear colleagues, dear friends,

It has been truly inspiring to listen to the discussions at this conference, and I am delighted to join you in these important reflections.

We meet at a time when geopolitical upheaval, economic pressure, and digital change are reshaping our societies, and forcing those who govern to adapt at speed.

In that spirit, I have also adapted my remarks at speed – some of them very late last night. So, if I pause at some point, it is not for dramatic effect – I am simply trying to decipher my own handwriting.

Such times remind us, more than ever, why our role matters: to preserve democracy and uphold the rights of citizens.

We all share a simple conviction: public power must be exercised fairly, transparently, and in the service of the people. But we also know that we can only give that conviction real meaning if we are fully independent.

So today, I want to reflect on three things: how our independence can be undermined, how we can preserve it, and how we can work together – across all our networks including the European Network of Ombudsmen that I have the privilege of coordinating – so that our collective voice remains strong and clear.

Let me start with why independence matters so much.

It is what gives credibility to our work and encourages people to trust us. It ensures that our conclusions follow the evidence, the law, and the principles of good administration – not the preferences of those we scrutinise.

And because we are an essential part of the checks and balances of a healthy democracy, our independence is not simply an institutional matter. It is essential for democracy itself.

But how secure is this independence in practice? Independence can be undermined in many ways – and not always through direct political interference.

Sometimes the pressure is financial or operational. How does one maintain independence if an office is severely under-resourced? How does one fulfil a widening mandate without the necessary staff and expertise? How does one ensure continuity when the appointment of a successor is delayed?

The European Commission's Rule of Law Reports document some of these pressures within the EU: budget cuts, refusals of reasoned requests for additional resources, wider mandates without corresponding means, and delays in appointing new ombudsmen when a mandate ends – and I know that many of you, well beyond the EU, recognise them only too well.

In other cases, the pressure is more direct. Some colleagues have come under pressure for championing human rights. Others face governments reluctant to accept scrutiny or recommendations that challenge established practices.

And there is another dimension we should not overlook: how our independence is perceived. We must remain impartial, even while naturally empathising with complainants. We must drive positive change without being perceived as political actors or activists. And we must be prepared to defend the legitimacy of our work when it is publicly questioned.

These pressures may take different forms, depending on our national circumstances and institutional arrangements. But they reveal a common vulnerability – and, therefore, a common cause.

So, what can we do?

To start, we need strong institutional safeguards: clear legal guarantees, transparent appointment procedures, secure mandates, adequate and predictable resources, and the powers necessary to carry out our work effectively.

But legal guarantees alone are not enough.

Independence is also something we build and demonstrate every day, through the quality and credibility of our work.

It requires us to be rigorous in our investigations, consistent in our reasoning, transparent in our procedures, and fair in our dealings with public authorities. It requires us to explain our findings clearly, including when they are difficult or unpopular.

We must also be accountable. Independence does not mean being beyond scrutiny. On the contrary, openness about our methods, decisions, and results reinforces our legitimacy.

But there is one further point I want to emphasise: no ombudsman should have to defend their independence alone. Regionally through AOM, globally through IOI, across the EU through ENO. Each of our networks carries its own history, its own geography, and its own strengths. None of them is a substitute for the others; together they form a web of solidarity that no single institution could weave alone.

I applaud the decision to place cooperation and solidarity among our institutions on the agenda of this conference – and I thank the AOM, also our host, for so faithfully embodying that spirit across the Mediterranean. A region where so many of our challenges meet.

Allow me to speak of the network I know from the inside. I do so not to hold it up as a model, but to share one experience among many – in the hope that it resonates with yours, and that yours may enrich ours.

As the coordinator of ENO – a task I am immensely proud of – let me pay tribute to what we have built over the last three decades.

A few weeks ago, thanks to the contributions of ENO offices across the EU, we published a report marking our 30th anniversary.

It shows that, despite our different sizes and mandates, EU law is the common thread that binds us.

We have built a community of expertise, experience, and shared values. Within ENO, I believe we should now make greater use of this community. I see – at least – three ways of doing so, and I suspect many of you, even in other networks, are asking the same questions.

First, we should make ENO a stronger forum for protecting institutional independence.

Building on our exchanges at the ENO conference in Brussels last November, we could develop a more systematic approach to mutual support: early dialogue when one of our institutions comes under strain; a space to share experiences, identify emerging threats and discuss how best to respond; and exchanges on appointment procedures, budgetary arrangements, legal safeguards, and the practical challenges of undue interference.

And, where appropriate, we could offer collective support when the independence of a member institution is challenged – through statements, dialogue with relevant European bodies, or other forms of solidarity.

I would like us to think of ENO as a kind of early-warning and mutual-support system.

Second, we could also use ENO more systematically for practical cooperation.

We are already delivering.

This year we launched two new joint inquiries. One concerning the EU food safety alert system and the other, led by the Slovenian Ombudsman, dedicated to EU climate law.

But there is more potential to explore: sharing investigative methods, expertise and training; developing exchanges between our staff; and identifying issues where coordinated work could bring greater results than individual action.

This, too, strengthens independence. The more expertise we share, the stronger our institutions become, and the better equipped we are to scrutinise administrations that operate across borders.

Third, we should develop a stronger collective voice.

There are European and international institutions that play an important role in safeguarding the independence of ombudsman institutions, including the Venice Commission.

We should make better use of these relationships and speak with one voice when common principles are at stake – also in concert with IOI, or AOM, where appropriate.

ENO can also give greater visibility to the challenges faced by individual members and bring them into the European debate on democracy and the rule of law.

This does not mean that we should all speak in exactly the same way. Our strength lies precisely in our diversity. But on the fundamental importance of independence, we should be able to stand together.

Put plainly, it is time to think of our networks more strategically: a community that can strengthen each of our institutions, amplify our influence, and offer a protective shield to any office in difficulty.

None of this belongs to one network alone. The pressures we face know no borders, and neither should our solidarity. I would warmly welcome closer exchanges between ENO, the AOM, and our partners beyond Europe, so that we learn from one another rather than in parallel.

So let this be a rallying call – for each of the networks represented here, and for all of us who share this calling.

I have said before that ombudsmen are optimists at heart. Otherwise, we would not be able to do our jobs. We believe in a society where people can expect power to be exercised fairly, their complaints to be taken seriously and institutions to be held to account.

Our independence serves this belief. When we strengthen it, we strengthen the credibility of democratic institutions. When we cooperate across borders and support one another, we make the protection of rights more consistent and effective.

We need each other more than ever: to amplify our role in defending democratic governance, to protect the independence that makes our work possible, and to draw strength from our collective resilience – here in the Mediterranean, across Europe, and beyond.

Cyprus is home to olive trees that have stood for centuries, through drought, storms, and changing times. Deep roots, patient strength,  and a symbol of peace: a fitting description of what an ombudsman institution should be.

Thank you.