- EN English
Opening speech at “The State of the Ethics Union” event by European Policy Centre (EPC)
Speech - Speaker Emily O'Reilly - City Brussels - Country Belgium - Date Friday | 08 September 2023
Good morning and thank you for inviting me to speak here today on a topic incessantly debated since the Belgian police kicked off Qatargate last December. So, as an anniversary looms, what has changed?
I’d like first of all however to thank Daniel Freund for providing a rather lovely metaphor relating to a report containing a series of proposals prompted by EP President Metsola’s 14 point reform plan and which was voted on yesterday by Parliament’s Constitutional Affairs Committee, AFCO.
This report, which will be put to the plenary in Strasbourg next week would essentially change some rules of the game when it comes to MEPs’ ethical conduct.
Daniel said that his colleagues’ approach to the tabling of amendments was rather like throwing spaghetti at a wall. They hoped, he said, that at least some of them would stick.
I think even close observers of this process would appreciate that metaphor as attempting to unravel the plethora of initiatives, abandoned initiatives, proposals, counter proposals and failed proposals has been indeed rather like disentangling spaghetti.
Two major strands and one central political division quickly appeared. Commission Vice President Jourova set about getting agreement on a long promised
inter-institutional ethics body, while President Metsola sought to get wide political agreement on her 14 point plan.
Familiar divisions began to emerge despite entreaties not to turn Qatargate into a political football. I’m sure Daniel Freund can explain yesterday’s AFCO vote and its relevance in addition to what is likely to happen at the Strasbourg plenary next week.
On its substance however, there are some improvements to the rules although implementation and monitoring will be critical. Rules around lobby meetings, declarations of interests, the acceptance of gifts, assets and side income will be strengthened but MEPs can continue to have those side jobs if they choose – a matter of concern in some cases where the line between public representative and private interest influencer becomes blurred.
A proposal to appoint three independent experts to advise the EP’s Advisory Committee on its enforcement of the Code of Conduct is a welcome one as is the proposal to allow the Committee to be proactive if alleged breaches are brought to its attention. As ever, the devil is on the detail but even this limited move away from complete self-regulation is positive.
On the Commission side, it has now held two preliminary meetings with the institutions concerning the proposed new inter-institutional ethics body, described as a standards setting body but explicitly informal and with no investigative or sanctioning powers.
Its so far proposed limited mandate again shows the lack of any shared political appetite for the kind of robust ethics regime that many citizens would have imagined was implicitly and explicitly proposed by Commission President von der Leyen. An inter institutional ethics body may shortly exist in name but its nature is likely to be far from what was widely understood to have been implied back in 2019.
This is not to suggest however that nothing has changed or that improvements will not be made. The proposed new ethics body – even if toothless when it comes to investigating or sanctioning - could at least compel the institutions to look at their own ethics regimes, to compare and contrast them with those of other bodies, to defend their internal rules or be forced - if only by peer pressure- to strengthen them.
At the very least it puts the matter of ethics much more front and centre of institutional thinking than was previously the case.
But whatever success it does have very much depends on the dynamic of the body. It can choose – or those who lead the institutions it represents can choose – to take its work seriously and engage philosophically and concretely with its task or it can just go through the motions and accept whatever lowest common denominator standard that can secure the agreement of all.
But if we step back a bit from all of this; what essentially is being attempted at least by those who genuinely want positive change in the ethics architecture of the EU is to protect it from corruption, internal and external, and to safeguard the decision making process of the legislators from malign or inappropriate influence.
From my perspective, there are two vital areas of influence that are not so far front and centre of this ethics debate - the Transparency Register and the issue of revolving doors.
The major concerns around the Register are that it is under resourced and fails to capture what is needed for an accurate, forensic accounting of who and how EU legislation is being influenced.
There have been repeated media and civil society reports of the disparity between what is reported re spend and personnel resources by certain corporations and the visible, on the ground reality.
On revolving doors, our multiple investigations repeatedly find a tendency to minimise the impact of the revolving door phenomenon on the integrity of our democratic decision-making processes.
This attitude also ignores the clear evidence of the corrosive impact of this form of soft corruption on our democracies and on regulatory outcomes.
A 2021 OECD survey across mature democracies found that nearly half of respondents believed that an elected or appointed official would accept a well-paid job in the private sector in exchange for a political favour.
If nearly half the electorate, rightly or wrongly, believe that politicians are treating meetings with industry chiefs that they are ostensibly regulating as a kind of job interview, this partly explains the widespread cynicism and dissatisfaction with our democratic systems.
Perceptions aside, the impact on our well-being and livelihoods is real and well documented. In the last decade, for example, Americans have experienced an unprecedented rise in mortality and a decline in life-expectancy unique in the developed world. Much of this increase is due to so-called ‘deaths of despair’ such as from alcohol and drug poisoning.
Much of the focus has been on the bribery and fraud perpetrated by one company, Perdue Pharma, for which it was successfully prosecuted by the US Department of Justice in 2020, receiving a record fine of over 3.5 Bn for a pharmaceutical company.
However, overseeing the opioid crisis was the US Food and Drug Administration. In the Purdue case, the two principal FDA reviewers who originally approved Purdue’s oxycodone application both took up positions at Purdue after leaving the agency.
Over the past 20 years, several other FDA staff involved in opioid approvals also left the FDA to work for opioid makers. According to the American Medical Association’s Journal of Ethics: “The FDA has never been held to account for its improper handling of the opioid crisis, but the FDA’s conduct is all the more troubling in light of the close relationship between the agency officials responsible for opioid oversight and opioid manufacturers.”
Moreover, the revolving door between the FDA and the pharmaceutical industry is not limited to opioids. A 2018 study found that 11 of 16 FDA medical reviewers involved in approving 28 products now work for the companies whose products they regulated. And the history of the 2008 financial crisis is also riddled with revolving door scandals.
We may regard this as a singularly American failing, a symptom of the excessive deference to corporate capitalism in the US system. But our own revolving door, at all levels, has led to no less devastating outcomes for our citizens and societies.
Europe’s fatal addiction over the last decade has not been to prescription opioids but to Russian gas, an addiction that has proved no less deadly for thousands of Ukrainians as it very likely emboldened Putin’s regime to make the gamble it did last February.
This dependency was steadily and deliberately nurtured through a strategy of co-opting members of the political elite across the EU, often via the revolving door into well-paying positions at Russian state-owned companies including most notoriously the ex-German chancellor Gerhard Schroeder who sits on the board of Gazprom.
I have no doubt but that in decades to come we will also be able to trace a line from failures to tackle the climate crisis to similar phenomena.
How many lobbyists, how many former EU institutional insiders will be found to have worked to prevent, delay or dilute necessary climate action? How many lives and livelihoods will be lost as a result?
We cannot be complacent.
In the US we are witnessing events unthinkable even ten years ago, the effective co -opting of large swathes of the US political class and public into the destructive, dystopian profoundly narcissistic mindset of just one man, his party opponents so cowed by his perceived power that they dare not challenge him.
Not a single one of the other contenders for his party’s Presidential nomination for example, dared to raise their hands in agreement when asked during a TV debate if they thought climate change was provoked by the actions of humans.
We may be light years away from all of that in Europe but all the little political and administrative corruptions that were left to go unchecked for decades in the US should serve as a warning of what can happen if a loose ethics regime eventually implodes.