FOR PREVIEWING & TESTING PURPOSES ONLY.
This notification will disappear once the page will be published.
This link is available for less than 30 minutes.
  • Easy to read
  • Text size

You have a complaint against an EU institution or body?

Current language: 
  • English
Available languages: 

Proposal for a solution on the European Commission’s refusal to give public access to the minutes of meetings of the EU Regional Task Force Greece (case 2237/2024/AML)

Made in accordance with Article 2(10) of the Statute of the European Ombudsman[1]

Background to the complaint

1. In 2015, the European Commission presented its European agenda on migration.[2] The Agenda introduced the ‘hotspot approach’, whereby the EU and its Member States work together to manage migration at the external borders of the EU. To support the implementation of the hotspot approach, the Commission set up EU Regional Task Forces (EURTF) to facilitate operational cooperation and information exchange. Participants in EURTF meetings included representatives of the Commission, EU Agencies (such as Frontex, Europol, the European Union Agency for Asylum, or Eurojust) and in some instances national authorities. Task Forces have played a significant role in implementing the EU approach to migration over the past decade.

2. In September 2021, the complainant, a researcher, made a request for public access to documents[3] held by the Commission. The request covered ‘Minutes from the EU Regional Task Force meetings in Greece 1) From June 2015 until September 2016; 2) From May 2018 until December 2018; and 3) From April 2020 until September 2021’.

3. In December 2021, the Commission adopted its initial decision, in which it identified 34 documents[4] as falling within the scope of the request, and refused access to all of them.

4. The complainant asked the Commission to review its decision in January 2022 (by making a ‘confirmatory application’).

5. In February 2023, the Commission adopted its confirmatory decision on the access request. In its decision, the Commission provided partial access to 27 documents and refused access to the seven remaining documents in their entirety. In doing so, it relied to the need to protect the public interest as regards public security and international relations,[5] and the protection of personal data.[6]

6. On 3 December 2024, dissatisfied with the Commission’s decision, the complainant turned to the Ombudsman.

The inquiry

7. The Ombudsman opened an inquiry into the Commission’s refusal to give (wider) public access to the minutes of meetings of the EURTF Greece. As the complainant did not challenge the redaction of information based on the need to protect personal data, this was not part of the Ombudsman’s inquiry.

8. During the inquiry, the Ombudsman inquiry team inspected the documents at issue, as well as the documents including the third-party consultations conducted by the Commission in relation to the access request.

9. The Ombudsman inquiry team met with Commission representatives in order to clarify a number of questions following the inspection of documents, and received the complainant’s comments on the meeting report. 

10. The Commission did not provide an additional written reply on the complaint, as it considered that its position had been set out in the confirmatory decision.

Arguments presented to the Ombudsman

11. In its confirmatory decision, the Commission argued that it was not possible to give wider access to the requested documents for the following reasons: 

i.Protection of the public interest as regards public security: The documents contain operational information related to border management, including possible shortcomings and proposed solutions, as well as information related to criminal activities. In this context, any access to the most recent meeting minutes from 2020 and 2021 (documents 29-35) must be refused as they contain ‘information on recent operational activities on the ground, situational and risk analysis, description of actions of organised trafficking circuits and operational tactics’. This information, if disclosed, would put at risk ongoing operations conducted by the Greek national police, coast guard authorities, and Frontex. Similarly, the wider disclosure of the requested minutes from older meetings, contained in documents 1-28, would reveal details about activities and methods that could then be used by malicious actors, thus undermining EU efforts in tackling cross-border crime and unauthorised border crossings. 

ii.Protection of the public interest as regards international relations: The documents requested refer to the cooperation with the authorities of an identified third country, including possible shortcomings and non-public details on cooperation in the field of border control and organised crime prevention. Disclosing this information would undermine Greece’s legitimate national interests and international relations with the third country concerned. The fact that the meetings were chaired by the Commission - and not by Greece - does not affect this conclusion, as the responsibilities of both the Commission (DG HOME) and Europol also have an external dimension.

12. During the meeting with the Ombudsman inquiry team, the Commission representatives further explained that the cooperation within the EURTF is founded on trust. Disclosing these exchanges could have a chilling effect, in turn putting at risk the mission of the EURTF. As a consequence, the Commission consulted the participants in EURTF meetings - who opposed disclosure to various extents[7] - and then sought to strike a balance between transparency, on the one hand, and their objections, on the other. The assessment of harm was carried out fully by the Commission. It did not merely conduct a prima facie assessment of the arguments of the Greek authorities.

13. The Commission representatives further emphasised that, in striking that balance, the passage of time was duly taken into consideration. While the mere fact that time has passed does not automatically render information less sensitive, it is a relevant factor to consider as it may decrease the risk of harm. This is the reason why partial access could be granted to documents 1-28 (dating from 2016-2018), but not to documents 29-35 (dating from 2020-2021). The latter category contained information related to ongoing Frontex operations and information that the Commission assessed to be of a similar nature.  

14. Finally, the Commission noted that, while it is true that in a previous application concerning a similar document,[8] no consultation took place and the document was disclosed almost in full (with the exception of personal data), this did not mean that the same should apply to the documents at issue.

15. The complainant considered that the Commission had made an excessive use of the relevant exceptions, failing, in particular, to demonstrate any serious and actual risk arising from the full (or very wide) disclosure of the information concerned. Besides underlining the Commission’s inconsistency in granting very wide access to a similar document in the past, the complainant submitted the following specific arguments.

16. The complainant argued that the Commission made a manifest error of assessment in applying the two exceptions. In support of this claim, the complainant underlined that it is clear from the partially disclosed documents that EURTF meetings do not deal solely with matters of public security, but also cover information that is ‘humanitarian’ rather than ‘security-related’ in nature (as indicated by headings on maintenance, medical services, interpretation, etc.). In addition, the complainant further emphasised that several years had passed between the meetings at issue and the adoption of the confirmatory decision. In the meantime, material, legal, and migratory circumstances had changed. For instance, none of the facilities to which the documents relate exist anymore, and relations with the third country in question had considerably evolved since 2016. The complainant thus took the view that the information contained in the documents, far from relating to sensitive operational details, was in fact not just outdated but historical in nature; and that the Commission had failed to properly take into consideration the impact of the passage of time on its sensitivity.

17. The complainant further took issue with the Commission’s reliance on the objections and arguments of the third parties consulted[9] in the handling of the access request. Emphasising that many of these third-party arguments seemed unjustified due to the passage of time (for the same reasons developed in paragraph 16), the complainant recalled that the Commission is bound to override objections to disclosure when they violate the principle of the widest possible access. In this particular case, the complainant was unconvinced that the Commission had conducted the independent assessment required, and also noted with concern that the Commission appeared not to have consulted (all) third parties again at the confirmatory stage, despite the objections of these third parties at initial stage being mostly time-related. 

18. Finally, and as regards the Commission’s argument that it is essential to preserve trust - and thus the confidential sharing of information - in EURTF meetings, the complainant recalled that all actors participating in those meetings, including the Greek authorities, are aware of their transparency obligations. The complainant noted that the Ombudsman has, in the past, emphasised the importance of transparency in relation to EU involvement in migration management activities.[10] In the complainant’s view, providing full access to the requested documents would be an important step in that direction.

The Ombudsman's assessment

19. The documents at issue in this inquiry can be divided into three categories, based on their dates and the extent of access granted:

i.Category I documents, covering documents 1-20 - meetings from 2016, and to which wide partial access was granted;

ii.Category II documents, covering documents 21-28 - meetings from 2018, and to which partial access was granted;

iii.Category III documents, covering documents 29-35 - meetings from 2020 and 2021, and to which no access was granted.

20. Given that the Commission granted wide partial access to Category I documents and that the remaining redactions in these documents do not suggest a manifest error of assessment on the Commission’s part, the Ombudsman’s solution proposal does not cover them. 

21. As regards Category II and III documents, the Ombudsman’s assessment is set out below.

22. One of the principles underpinning public access to documents under Regulation 1049/2001 is that openness enables citizens to participate more closely in the decision-making processes and guarantees greater accountability of the EU administration in a democratic system.[11] Timeliness plays an important role in achieving that purpose, both because it can impact the relevance of documents to requesters,[12] and because it can affect the confidentiality of documents. It is in part for these reasons that it is important that EU institutions process access requests as swiftly as possible, and in any case within the deadlines provided for by Regulation 1049/2001.[13]

23. Such considerations are of particular relevance to this case.

24. First, the nature of Category III documents at the time of the access request - that is, documents which the Commission considered to have been drawn up recently - appeared to play an important role in the Commission’s refusal to grant access to them. Similarly, in the meeting with the Ombudsman inquiry team, the Commission representatives justified redactions to Category II documents by the fact that they contain information related to ‘ongoing discussions’, which have ‘remained broadly the same’.

25. Second, the Commission largely exceeded the statutory time limits for dealing with the access request both at the initial and at the confirmatory stage. Almost 17 months lapsed between the moment when the complainant made the access request, and the Commission’s confirmatory decision. The Commission representatives stated, in their meeting with the Ombudsman inquiry team, that they had assessed the documents’ sensitivity at the time of the confirmatory decision. However, the Ombudsman is not convinced that these 17 months were sufficiently taken into account when deciding on the extent of the access to be granted. Specifically:

i.As regards Category III documents, the fact that some of the most recent documents were no longer a few months old (as they were when the initial application was received), but between two and three years old, and how this affected the assessment that they related to ‘ongoing operations’, was not fully addressed in the confirmatory decision. In this context, the Ombudsman regrets that the third party which had most opposed disclosure of some of these documents based on their recent nature was not consulted again at confirmatory stage. It cannot be excluded that, a year and a half later, this third party would have provided different input on the disclosure of the documents. It is also unclear why the Commission considered that the entirety of the documents related to ‘ongoing operations’ was sensitive, while in fact they appear to contain a variety of (types of) information, some of which was widely disclosed in Category I and II documents, and even entirely disclosed in the minutes of another EURTF meeting of the same year (to which the Commission granted full access).[14]

ii.As regards Category II documents, many of the redactions, especially those related to contributions from the Greek authorities, appear to cover possibly outdated and non-actionable information related to facilities that did not exist anymore (since many of the facilities currently in operation in the region have been opened since 2021, progressively replacing the infrastructures mentioned in the documents) and facts that were outdated (nationalities of those in the facilities, living conditions, repairs, presence or absence of interpreters, general information about returns, etc.). Yet, the confirmatory decision did not sufficiently address this.

26. In light of the above, the Ombudsman considers that the Commission did not adequately take into account the passage of time and the change in circumstances when handling this public access request as regards Category II and III documents.

27. Moreover, three years have passed since the Commission adopted its confirmatory decision in this case. As such, the Ombudsman’s view is that the most appropriate course of action is that the Commission now reassesses the request for access to documents in light of the present circumstances, with a view to granting wider (partial) access to Category II and III documents (documents 21-35). In doing so, the Ombudsman invites the Commission to take into consideration her observations set out above, and encourages the Commission to consult again the participants to EURTF meetings.

The proposal for a solution

The Ombudsman proposes that the Commission reassess documents 21-35, taking into account the passage of time and possible changes in circumstances, with a view to granting wider (partial) access. If the Commission maintains redactions, it should explain why certain parts of the documents still need to be withheld at present.

The Commission is invited to inform the Ombudsman by 14 July 2026 of any action it has taken in relation to the above solution proposal.

Teresa Anjinho 
European Ombudsman 

Strasbourg, 13/04/2026 

 

[1] Available at: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=uriserv%3AOJ.L_.2021.253.01.0001.01.ENG&toc=OJ%3AL%3A2021%3A253%3ATOC

[2] COM(2015) 240 final, available at: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=celex:52015DC0240

[3] Under Regulation (EC) No 1049/2001 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 30 May 2001 regarding public access to European Parliament, Council and Commission documents (“Regulation 1049/2001”), available at: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2001/1049/oj/eng

[4] The documents were erroneously numbered as 1-35 (instead of 1-34), due to a clerical error. For the sake of clarity, the same numbering is used in this solution proposal.

[5] Respectively Article 4(1)(a), first and third indent of Regulation 1049/2001.

[6] Article 4(1)(b) of Regulation 1049/2001.

[7] Specifically, the Greek authorities opposed disclosure on the basis of the exceptions protecting public security and international relations, while Europol requested the redaction of its contributions on the basis of public security exception. Frontex asked for non-disclosure of parts of documents 1-31 and of the entirety of documents 32-35. Both the Greek authorities and Europol were consulted at the initial and confirmatory stages, whereas Frontex was consulted at the initial stage.

[8] Minutes of the 67th meeting of the EURTF, 5 March 2020.

[9] In accordance with Article 4(4) of Regulation 1049/2001.

[10] See in particular the European Ombudsman’s decisions in the strategic inquiry OI/3/2022/MHZ on how the European Commission ensures respect for fundamental rights in EU-funded migration management facilities in Greece (available at: https://www.ombudsman.europa.eu/en/decision/en/170792) and in the case 1418/2023/VS on how the European Commission monitors fundamental rights compliance in the context of EU funds granted to Greece for border management (available at: https://www.ombudsman.europa.eu/en/decision/en/200015).

[11] Recital (2) of Regulation 1049/2001.

[12] The Ombudsman has regularly taken the view, over the past years, that access delayed is access denied, and that systemic delays in handling access requests amounts to maladministration. For instance, see the Ombudsman’s decision on the time the European Commission takes to deal with requests for public access to documents (strategic inquiry OI/2/2022/OAM), available at: https://www.ombudsman.europa.eu/en/decision/en/175321.

[13] See for instance the Ombudsman’s decision in case 344/2023/PVV, in which the Ombudsman called Frontex to take into account the passage of time and change of circumstances when replying to her solution proposal (available at: https://www.ombudsman.europa.eu/en/decision/en/192720); as well as the Ombudsman’s decision in case 318/2024/TM, in which the Commission, in light of the change of circumstances, adopted a new initial decision and granted wider partial access to the documents at issue (available at: https://www.ombudsman.europa.eu/en/decision/en/195112).

[14] Specifically, the Commission appears to have granted access in full (to the exception of personal data) to the minutes of the 67th meeting of the EURTF, which took place in March 2020. In parallel, it refused access in full to minutes of meetings that took place in September, October, and November of the same year (documents 29, 30, and 31).