- EN English
Decision of the European Ombudsman on complaint 1391/2002/JMA against the European Commission
Decision
Case 1391/2002/JMA - Opened on Monday | 16 September 2002 - Recommendation on Friday | 27 February 2004 - Special report on Monday | 16 September 2002 - Decision on Tuesday | 07 June 2005
The complaint was lodged by a Commission official and concerns the failure of the European Schools to cater for the special educational needs of the complainant's child. Since the European Schools could not meet those special needs, the complainant was compelled to take her child to an alternative education system, the costs of which were not entirely covered by the Commission. Instead, the institution required the complainant to make a financial contribution to the cost of her child's special education.
In the course of the inquiry into this complaint, the Ombudsman received a significant number of additional complaints which involved similar facts and raised identical allegations. Those complaints were made part of the inquiry and treated jointly.
As a result of his investigation, the Ombudsman took the view that the integration of children with special educational needs (SEN children) into the ordinary education system remains a general policy goal, albeit without a mandatory character. In the absence of a binding legal provision, the Ombudsman did not find that the fact that the complainant’s child could not be educated in one of the European Schools constituted maladministration. The Ombudsman nevertheless found that the financial aspects of the situation constituted an unjustified discrimination, and made a draft recommendation to the Commission inviting it to take the necessary steps to ensure that parents of SEN children who are excluded from the European Schools because of their degree of disability should not be required to contribute to the educational costs of their children.
The Commission's detailed opinion as well as the additional information sent by its services did not unequivocally accept the draft recommendation. Nor did these documents indicate that the Commission appeared willing to reverse its policy on charging officials for the education of their SEN children. The Ombudsman therefore considered it appropriate to make a Special Report on the matter to the European Parliament and to include the recommendation made to the Commission.
Strasbourg, 7 June 2005
Dear Mrs N.,
On 25 July 2002, you lodged a complaint with the European Ombudsman against the European Commission, concerning the failure of the European Schools to cater for the special educational needs of your daughter.
On 27 May 2005, following an in-depth inquiry into your complaint, including a draft recommendation to the Commission, I submitted a special report to the European Parliament, in accordance with Article 3 (7) of the Statute of the Ombudsman. The special report recommends that the Commission should take the necessary steps to ensure that parents of children with special educational needs (SEN children) that are excluded from the European Schools because of their degree of disability are not required to contribute to the educational costs of their children.
I am enclosing with this letter a copy of my special report.
The Statute of the Ombudsman provides for the submission of a report to the European Parliament to be the final step in an inquiry by the Ombudsman. I therefore close the file on the complaint.
The President of the Commission will also be informed of this decision.
Yours sincerely,
P. Nikiforos DIAMANDOUROS