FOR PREVIEWING & TESTING PURPOSES ONLY.
This notification will disappear once the page will be published.
This link is available for less than 30 minutes.
  • Easy to read
  • Text size

You have a complaint against an EU institution or body?

Current language: 
  • English
Available languages: 

Report on the meeting of the European Ombudsman inquiry team with representatives of the European Commission on its refusal to give public access to the minutes of meetings of the EU Regional Task Force Greece

Date: Thursday, 12 June 2025

Remote meeting arrangements

Present

European Commission

Four representatives of the Commission Secretariat General

Seven representatives of DG HOME

European Ombudsman

Amandine Le Bellec, Inquiries officer

Jennifer King, Legal expert

Nicholas Hernanz, Inquiries officer

Ainara Gomez Urrosolo, Inquiries trainee

Background

The inquiry concerns the European Commission’s refusal to give (full) public access to the minutes of meetings of the EU Regional Task Force Greece (EURTF) that took place between 2016 and 2021. The Commission identified 34 documents as falling within the scope of the request. It granted access to parts of 27 documents and refused access to the remaining documents in their entirety. In doing so, it invoked exceptions under the EU legislation on public access to documents (Regulation 1049/2001),[1] arguing that disclosure could undermine the protection of the public interest as regards public security and international relations, and the protection of personal data.

Purpose of the meeting

The purpose of the meeting was for the Ombudsman inquiry team to obtain further information about how the Commission handled the public access request and applied the public security and international relation exceptions under Regulation 1049/2001, also taking into account the passage of time in this case. The Ombudsman inquiry team had shared a list of questions with the Commission ahead of the meeting.

Introduction and procedural information

The Ombudsman inquiry team introduced themselves, thanked the Commission representatives for meeting with them and set out the purpose of the meeting. They outlined the legal framework that applies to meetings held by the Ombudsman, in particular, that the Ombudsman would not disclose any information identified by the Commission as confidential, neither to the complainant nor to any other person outside the Ombudsman’s Office, without the Commission’s prior consent.[2]

The inquiry team explained that they would draw up a draft report on the meeting to be sent to the Commission to ensure that the contents were factually accurate and complete. The meeting report would then be finalised, included in the file and provided to the complainant. No confidential information would be included in the report or otherwise provided to the complainant or any third party.

Information exchanged

The representatives from the Commission first provided contextual information about the case. They explained that they had been dealing with two related public access requests from the same applicant, one about the EURTF in Greece, and another about the EURTF in Italy. In that context, the Commission partially disclosed a total of 105 meeting minutes. The Commission’s confirmatory decision on the access request related to the EURTF in Italy was not challenged.

The Commission representatives further noted that, as the complaint to the Ombudsman was filed almost two years after the Commission’s confirmatory decision was adopted, the assessment of the sensitivity of the information contained in the documents should be done in the appropriate context. They underlined that when handling the request they took into consideration the circumstances applicable at the time of the confirmatory decision.

Application of the public security and international relations exceptions

The Commission representatives underlined that migration is a politicised topic, in the context of which certain security-related incidents may arise, which the Commission and other authorities try to address through the EURTF. There is no obligation for Member States to share information in this forum. Cooperation with stakeholders and partners is thus firmly founded on trust, established over years. The Commission representatives explained that, in consideration of the above, theyconsulted the Greek authorities (twice) on the disclosure of these exchanges and Greek authorities clearly explained why they oppose disclosure. The subsequent disclosure of these exchanges may have a chilling effect, which would put at risk the effectiveness of the EURTF fulfilling its mission. The Commission therefore took into account the opinions of third parties consulted on the access requests in order to protect the integrity of those discussions. The Commission representatives stated that this does not mean that transparency standards are lowered.

As regards the application of the relevant exceptions, the Commission representatives explained that although the documents at issue date from several years ago, they nonetheless relate to ongoing discussions on migration management. They stated that the essence of what was discussed in the EURTF meetings - and now discussed in other fora, such as Steering Committee meetings - has remained broadly the same. The Commission has identified four main risks if the documents were to be disclosed (more widely):

1.Risks of misrepresentation and misuse of information if operational details were to be disclosed. Specifically, although infrastructures such as migration management facilities may have changed, operational practices (screening, patrolling, security checks, etc.) are similar, and thus remain relevant today;

2.Risks of exposure of operational shortcomings (including persistent ones) and possible use of these shortcomings by external actors;

3.Risks to public and national security by disclosing actionable intelligence details that could be used, for instance, to adapt malicious activity patterns;

4.Risks to bilateral relations between Greece and Türkiye, independent of the passage of time. 

The Commission representatives provided specific examples of information contained in the documents that would pose a risk to public security if they were disclosed, and provided detailed explanations of the harm in disclosure. In addition, they provided an example of information that could pose a risk to international relations. These examples are recorded in the confidential annex to this report.

The passage of time

The Ombudsman inquiry team noted that the documents at issue date from 2016 to 2018 (for those to which partial access was granted) and from 2020-2021 (for those to which no access was granted). The Commission adopted its initial decision in 2021, and its confirmatory decision in 2023. In light of this, the inquiry team asked the Commission how it had taken into account the passage of time in its assessment of the sensitivity of information and objections of third parties.

The Commission representatives explained that they considered the passage of time in their assessment, as well as during their consultations with third parties. During these consultations, the Commission specifically asked third parties to factor in the passage of time when providing their responses. The Commission representatives noted that at the time the application was submitted, some of the documents related to meetings that had taken place very recently. As a general rule, the mere fact that time has passed does not automatically render information less sensitive. However, it is a relevant factor to consider as it may decrease the risk of harm.

In the case at hand, both Greece and Europol opposed disclosure. Frontex requested the redaction of parts of documents 29-31 (2016-2020 meetings) and asked that documents 32-35 (2021 meetings) not be disclosed as they relate to ongoing operations. The Commission agreed with Frontex’s assessment as regards the documents from 2021 and further extended it to documents from 2020, which it considered to contain similar recent information. Following this, the Commission sought to strike a balance between transparency, on the one hand, and the objections of third parties, on the other. This is why the Commission granted partial access to the documents from 2016 to 2018, but refused access in full to those of 2020 and 2021, which were more recent and thus more sensitive.

In reply to a question from the Ombudsman inquiry team, the Commission representatives confirmed that Frontex was consulted only at the initial stage, and was not re-consulted at the confirmatory stage.

The Ombudsman inquiry team further asked the Commission representatives to comment on specific examples of information contained in the documents that, at first sight, do not appear sensitive. The Commission representatives explained that, although some of the facts mentioned in the documents may be publicly known, the documents go into more detail than what is available publicly, even today. In reply to an example of publicly available information in one document, the Commission representatives confirmed that this was a unique instance and that the vast majority of the information featured in the documents was not public.

Consultation with a Member State

The Commission representatives confirmed that the Greek authorities were consulted both at initial and confirmatory stages, and opposed the disclosure of the requested documents. In addition, the Commission did not seek to verify whether the information provided by Greece was classified at national level, as it was argued by Greece at initial stage given that the Commission cannot question or independently assess such national security classifications. This verification was not needed considering that the Commission did not overrule the objections of the Greek authorities. In addition, reference to such a classification may sometimes only be an indication that the information is considered sensitive, and/or may evolve over time. Moreover, when considering requests for access to documents, the Commission can base its confirmatory reply only on Regulation 1049/2001 and cannot rely on the national laws of a Member State. The Commission therefore based its assessment on the exceptions listed under Article 4 of Regulation 1049/2001.

The Commission representatives further clarified that the assessment of harm conducted in this case was a full assessment by the Commission, not solely a prima facie assessment of the arguments provided by the Greek authorities. 

Conclusion of the meeting

The inquiry team thanked the Commission’s representatives for their time and for the explanations provided, and the meeting ended.

Brussels, 27 August 2025

Jennifer King                                                                                                                         Amandine Le Bellec

Legal Expert                                                                                                                         Inquiries Officer



 

[1] Article 4(1)(a), first and third indent, of Regulation 1049/2001, available at: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2001/1049/oj/eng

[2] Article 4.8 of the European Ombudsman’s Implementing Provisions.