- EN English
Closing note on the strategic initiative into how the European Commission ensures that the revised rules governing the Joint Sickness Insurance Scheme (JSIS) for EU staff guarantee comprehensive coverage for disability-related health needs (SI/2/2024/AML)
Closing Note - Date Wednesday | 12 February 2025
Case SI/2/2024/AML - Opened on Friday | 16 February 2024 - Decision on Wednesday | 12 February 2025 - Institution concerned European Commission - Country France
Inquiry opened
16/02/2024Inquiry ongoing
16/02/2024Inquiry outcome
12/02/2025
The Ombudsman carried out this strategic initiative to follow up on her previous inquiry on how the health insurance scheme for EU staff members covers disability-related health needs. Following that inquiry, the European Commission committed to revise some of the rules governing the reimbursement of healthcare for EU staff members and their families. The revision took place in 2020 and introduced more flexibility to the notion of ‘serious illness’ to improve the coverage of disability-related expenses under that reimbursement category.
To examine whether the revision achieved the intended objective, the Ombudsman set out questions to the Commission about the new rules and their implementation. Based on the Commission’s reply, the Ombudsman concluded that she was not convinced that the revision has substantially improved the situation of staff members with disabilities or who have a family member with disabilities. She was also disappointed with how the Commission had followed up on the issue over the past decade.
The Ombudsman urged the Commission to start effectively monitoring the situation of persons with disabilities under the EU health insurance scheme and to explore other measures that could make that scheme more compliant with the United Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities.
Background
1. The United Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (UNCRPD) is an international human rights treaty, which entered into force in 2008. Following decades of activism by the disability rights movement, the UNCRPD affirmed at the international level the political, civil, economic, social and cultural rights of persons with disabilities.
2. The EU is a party to the UNCRPD, which it applies since 2011. Consequently, the EU as an employer has an obligation to recognise the right of persons with disability to enjoy the “highest attainable standard of health”. The right to health notably includes access to free or affordable health care without discrimination, as well as the prohibition of discrimination in the provision of health insurance. These two elements are relevant to the health insurance scheme for EU staff members, the Joint Sickness Insurance Scheme (JSIS), which regulates the reimbursement of health-related costs based on the rules governing the employment of EU staff members (‘the Staff Regulations’),[1] and on general implementing provisions (GIPs) adopted by the Commission.
3. The compliance of the EU with its obligations under the UNCRPD is reviewed on a regular basis by a specialised body, the UN Committee on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (‘the UN Committee’).
4. In that context, in 2015, when the EU underwent its first review by the UN Committee, concerns were raised about the compliance of JSIS with the UNCRPD.[2] More precisely, during the review process, civil society organisations pointed that JSIS required persons with disabilities to prove that their disability was equivalent to a ‘serious illness’ to receive full reimbursement for their related health care. These organisations expressed concerns that this condition, as well as the criteria used to define ‘serious illness’, left many persons with disabilities with additional costs depending on their disability.[3] In its conclusions, the UN Committee raised concerns that EU staff members with disabilities or with family members with disabilities were discriminated against by JSIS.[4] It recommended a revision of the scheme to ensure comprehensive coverage for disability-related health needs in a manner that is compliant with the UNCRPD.
5. In 2016, the Ombudsman opened a strategic inquiry into the issue. In 2018, the Ombudsman found that the failure of the Commission to take any effective action in response to the Committee’s recommendation amounted to maladministration, and she recommended that the Commission revises the GIPs, which are the rules governing the operation of JSIS. She also made five suggestions for improvement.[5]
6. The Commission accepted the Ombudsman’s recommendation as well as four of the suggestions for improvement, and in 2020, the GIPs were updated.[6]
The initiative
7. The EU is undergoing a second periodic review and therefore the Ombudsman has taken that opportunity to reflect on what has been done since the first review.
8. In order to assess whether the changes introduced were effective in delivering concrete and positive change for EU staff members with disabilities or who have a family member with disabilities, the Ombudsman wrote to the Commission on 16 February 2024[7] requesting the Commission’s reply to the following questions:
A. How the Commission followed up on the Ombudsman’s recommendation and on three of her suggestions for improvement, and more broadly how the GIPs revision ensured that the JSIS was compliant with the UNCRPD;
B. How the criteria for assessing serious illness were applied to disability and what were the consequences if one or several of them were not fulfilled;
C. Whether any difference was made as regards the nature of the disability or its perceived ‘degree’ when deciding on full reimbursement;
D. How the Commission ensured that increased flexibility did not result in increased unpredictability of reimbursement;
E. What actions had the Commission taken in terms of awareness raising on the human rights approach to disability for EU health professionals and staff members working on the JSIS;
F. Any statistical overview that the Commission would have to monitor the situation.
9. The Ombudsman received the reply of the Commission on 10 July 2024.[8]
Replies of the Commission
10. As a general statement, the Commission emphasised its commitment to lead by example on the rights of persons with disabilities.[9] It explained that although its reply is focused on the revision and implementation of the GIPs, a wide range of other support measures is available to staff members with a disability or who have a family member with a disability.
Follow up on the findings of OI/4/2016/EA (question A)
11. As regards how the Commission followed up on the Ombudsman’s recommendation, the Commission first outlined the general framework for the reimbursement of healthcare under the Staff Regulations. It explained that following the reform of the Staff Regulations in 2013, they now define and complement the concepts of disability and reasonable accommodation in line with the UNCPRD. Further, it explained that medical costs are reimbursed by JSIS, which is an exclusively medical scheme. The regular reimbursement rules of JSIS, which apply to the medical costs of persons of disabilities, are as follows:
- In general, medical costs are reimbursed up to 80% or 85% depending on the type of treatment, regardless of whether the beneficiary has a disability or not;
- If a beneficiary - including a beneficiary with a disability - has a ‘serious illness’, the reimbursement is increased to 100% for all related medical costs.
12. The Commission explained that the Staff Regulations expressly list a number of illnesses for which reimbursement is increased to 100%.[10] Other illnesses recognised as of a ‘comparable seriousness’ also give rise to right to full reimbursement. For an illness to qualify as such, it must contain four elements listed in the GIPs as: (a) an illness which is likely to be drawn-out; (b) the need for aggressive diagnostic and/or therapeutic procedures; (c) the presence or risk of a serious handicap and (d) a shortened life expectancy.
13. While the four criteria are cumulative, the Commission explained that it had already in the past taken a flexible and holistic approach with regard to their fulfilment in individual cases. Following the Ombudsman’s inquiry in OI/4/2016/EA, in 2020, the Commission decided to codify this flexibility in the GIPs. Therefore, the Commission included the following statement after the list of criteria in the GIPs: “These cumulative criteria must be subject to an overall assessment of the seriousness of the consequences of the illness in question. Given the way in which they may be interlinked, the assessment of one of the criteria is likely to influence the assessment of the other criteria, particularly as regards cases of serious disability. The examination of one criterion in the light of the assessment of the other criteria may lead to the conclusion that the criterion in question, in particular the criterion relating to shortened life expectancy, has been fulfilled.”[11]
14. The Commission specified that this does not change the cumulative nature of the criteria. Thus, the “mere presence of a ‘serious handicap’ does not necessarily imply the recognition of a serious illness”.
15. Finally, the Commission stated that this targeted amendment of the GIPs is without prejudice to a more extensive revision of the GIPs in the future.
16. As regards the Ombudsman’s suggestions for improvement,[12] the Commission’s reply may be summarised as follows:
- Non-exhaustive list of reimbursable assistive devices: The process is complex and lengthy, also due to the fast evolution of the sector, but a dedicated team is currently compiling such a list, to complement the existing one in the GIPs;
- Training for managers and staff working on disability-related issues: The Commission induction course for new managers addresses the needs of staff with disabilities or who have family members with disabilities and further training and learning material is available online to all staff. The Diversity and Inclusion Office (DIO), set up in 2020 within the Directorate-general for Human Resources and Security, has organised a number of awareness-raising events and workshops in 2021 and 2022 on disability-related topics for managers, human resources professionals, other specific groups, and all staff;
- Consultation of associations of persons with disabilities: The Commission discusses legislative proposals and policies concerning staff members within the fora provided by the Staff Regulations (staff representatives and, in many cases, the Staff Committee), thus ensuring an involvement of the staff as a whole. The Commission also has regular contacts with disability-related associations of EU staff, who are consulted together with the Joint Committee on Equal Opportunities on proposals related to disability. Such consultations took place when the GIPs were revised in 2020.
Reimbursement of disability-related expenses under the new GIPs (questions B, C, and D)
17. Regarding how the four criteria are applied to persons with disabilities (question B), the Commission recalled that these criteria were based on an opinion from the Medical Council of JSIS at the time, which concluded that they represent elements common to all serious illnesses listed in the Staff Regulations. The purpose of these criteria remains to identify health conditions of a ‘comparable seriousness’ as those expressly listed. Therefore, the criteria remain cumulative and applicable equally to persons with or without a disability, even when assessing whether they are globally fulfilled or not in an individual situation.
18. The Commission explained that in practice, it has taken a ‘flexible and holistic approach’ in assessing the interdependence between these criteria. Medical officers establish the facts and also conduct a comprehensive medical assessment of those facts, during which they analyse each criterion independently and then globally assess their interdependence. In that context, the criterion of ‘the need for aggressive diagnostic and/or therapeutic procedure’ is important, especially when the illness has resulted or could result in a ‘serious handicap’. When heavy therapeutic or diagnostic measures (including important financial costs) are necessary in cases of (risk of) ‘serious handicap’, such measures may lead to the conclusion that the shortened life expectancy criterion is fulfilled, even if this was not established clearly.
19. As regards whether decisions on full reimbursement may vary depending on the type of impairment or their perceived ‘degree’ (question C), the Commission reiterated that the system for reimbursement under the Staff Regulations was intended to cover medical costs and that only such costs which are linked to a recognised serious illness are eligible for full reimbursement. It explained that, when it assesses the criterion of the presence or risk of ‘serious handicap’, the risk alone is sufficient for the criterion to be fulfilled. There is therefore no distinction based on the type of impairment, nor any assessment of the impact of that impairment on the functioning of the person or on their personal, household or social activities. What matters is the natural history of the illness and the medical diagnosis of the doctor in determining if such a risk exists or if it has materialised.
20. In reply to the question on the impact of flexibility on the predictability of reimbursements (question D), the Commission stated that while flexibility necessarily entails some unpredictability, this approach is more respectful of the need for an individual analysis of each file. The Commission stated that to ensure consistency and a harmonised approach, medical officers meet to discuss the most complex files twice a month, and once a serious illness is recognised, an internal list of measures eligible for full reimbursement is created by the medical officer to facilitate the processing of requests by the JSIS desk officer.
Awareness-raising and monitoring actions (questions E and F)
21. The two last questions of the Ombudsman related to the measures put in place by the Commission to ensure and monitor the implementation of a human rights approach to disability in JSIS, as required by the UNCRPD.
22. The Commission explained that, in terms of awareness raising around the CRPD and the human rights approach to disability (question E), its health professionals, as part of their national training, are bound by continuous training obligations and may therefore attend relevant external seminars. The Commission also advises them to follow an online training course on ‘Law, diversity policy and disability’ at national level. In addition, the seven members of the JSIS Settlement Office’s specialised team on disability provide a personal and dedicated approach to EU staff who have a disability or who have a family member with a disability. The members of this team work closely with the Commission and the human rights services of other institutions and also participate in relevant seminars or conferences.
23. Finally, the Commission did not have the statistical data (question F) requested by the Ombudsman regarding the number of disability-related applications received for the recognition of a serious illness submitted and their outcome. The Commission nonetheless stated that since 2020, it received 39 complaints under Article 90(2) of the Staff Regulations related to the non-recognition of a serious illness. While it could not ascertain the proportion of complaints submitted by persons with disabilities, it noted that in nine cases the applicant mentioned an alleged disability.
The Ombudsman's assessment
24. The UNCRPD states that persons with disabilities have the right to the enjoyment of the highest attainable standard of health without discrimination on the basis of disability. When ratifying the Convention, the EU, as a State Party, committed to take appropriate action in that field. This includes among others a commitment to prohibit discrimination in the provision of health insurance, which must be provided in a fair and reasonable manner.[13]
25. When, in 2016, the Ombudsman first looked into this matter, her inquiry followed the concerns of the UN Committee that JSIS discriminated against persons with disabilities. At the time, the Ombudsman found that the Commission’s failure to act on the recommendation of the UN Committee that JSIS be revised amounted to maladministration. She urged the Commission to interpret the Staff Regulations in light of the UNCRPD, and to amend the GIPs to ensure that they are more appropriate and effective in assessing the seriousness of the specific situation of persons with disabilities. The Ombudsman made a number of proposals on how this could be done in the GIPs, for instance by clarifying the current text, introducing specific additional provisions, or introducing a set of alternative criteria applicable to disability.[14]
26. The purpose of this strategic initiative was to assess whether the changes to JSIS introduced by the Commission effectively addressed the concerns expressed by the UN Committee in 2015 and by the Ombudsman in 2018. Unfortunately, based on the reply from the Commission, the Ombudsman is not convinced that this is the case, for the reasons set out below.
27. First, as regards the GIPs, the main change introduced by their revision in 2020 is the express codification of a practice that not only already existed, but was also already required under EU case law.[15] The nature and cumulative effect of the four criteria in cases of disability were unchanged. The 2020 revision of the GIPs thus largely maintains the system as it already existed before the UN Committee’s recommendation.
28. In light of this, the Ombudsman’s view is that such superficial changes are unlikely to be sufficient to address the UN Committee’s fundamental concern that JSIS discriminates against persons with disabilities. She recalls, as she did in 2018, that the principles of equal treatment and non-discrimination require that comparable situations must not be treated differently and that different situations must not be treated in the same way unless such treatment is objectively justified.[16] To give full effect to this, the Commission should take account both of the discrimination of persons with disabilities as a group (as the four criteria, although neutral in appearance, were not designed with disability in mind), and within their group (as impairments with comparable effects on daily life may, depending on their nature, fulfil more or less easily the four criteria). The Ombudsman invites once again the Commission to reflect on ways to revise the rules governing JSIS to ensure comprehensive coverage for disability-related health needs, in line with what the UN Committee has called for and as required from the EU as a State Party to the UNCRPD.
29. Second, as regards other measures to ensure compliance with the UNCRPD in the provision of healthcare and health insurance, the Ombudsman is concerned that the Commission may not meet the standards expected of it in terms of awareness raising, training and monitoring measures.
30. Specifically, under the current GIPs, compliance of JSIS with the UNCRPD mostly relies on the increased flexibility granted to the medical officer in charge of the file. Yet, the Commission does not seem to have developed training or guidance to ensure that its health professionals use this flexibility in line with the Convention.[17] Rather, it would seem that the Commission relies on the obligation of medical staff to undertake continuous professional development, but without reviewing the content of these programmes or holding further specific training on the human rights approach to disability in relation to the GIPs.
31. The Ombudsman is not convinced that the fact that the most complex files may be collegially discussed by medical officers is sufficient to guarantee consistency, predictability and compliance with the UNCRPD in the processing of disability-related files. This is even more worrying considering that it does not seem that the Commission has a system in place to monitor the number of applications for the recognition of ‘serious illness’ submitted by or on behalf of persons with disabilities and their outcome.[18] In light of the above, it is questionable how the Commission is able to affirm with certainty that JSIS is implemented in a manner that complies with the UNCRPD.
32. Thus, and while the Ombudsman welcomes and acknowledges the Commission’s efforts on some aspects of her previous inquiry, she remains disappointed with the overall level of engagement of the Commission with this issue over the past decade. She recalls that the UNCRPD contains explicit obligations for State Parties as regards the collection of information for the purpose of formulation and implementation of policies to give full effect to the Convention.[19] Against this background, she urges the Commission to start effectively monitoring the situation of persons with disabilities under JSIS and to explore other measures that could make that scheme compliant with the UNCRPD.
33. As a member of the EU Framework on the UNCRPD, the Ombudsman will continue to monitor the matter, and will await the outcome of the second review of the EU by the UN Committee.
Conclusions
The Ombudsman closes this strategic initiative with the following conclusions:
The Ombudsman is not convinced that the revision of the rules governing JSIS undertaken by the Commission in 2020 was sufficient to address the concerns of the UN Committee that JSIS discriminates against persons with disabilities.
The Ombudsman, as a member of the EU Framework on the UNCRPD, will continue to monitor this matter and will await the outcome of the second review of the EU by the UN Committee.
The Commission will be informed of this closing note.
Emily O'Reilly
European Ombudsman
Strasbourg, 12/02/2025
[1] Article 72 of Staff Regulations of Officials of the European Union and the Conditions of Employment of Other Servants (CEOS) as laid down by Council Regulation (EEC, Euratom, ECSC) No 259/68.
[2] Article 25 of the United Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities, available at: https://www.un.org/disabilities/documents/convention/convoptprot-e.pdf
[3] European Disability Forum Alternative Report on the Implementation of the UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities, p.75, available at: https://www.autismeurope.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/08/2015-03-04-edf-alternative-report-final-accessible.pdf
[4] Concluding observations on the initial report of the European Union, CRPD/C/EU/CO/1, para 86-87, available at: https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/812354?ln=en&v=pdf
[5] Full details about inquiry OI/4/2016/EA, the recommendation and the suggestions for improvement, are available at: https://www.ombudsman.europa.eu/en/decision/en/112191
[6] Commission Decision C(2020) 3002 final.
[7] Letter and list of questions available at: https://www.ombudsman.europa.eu/en/opening-summary/en/18217 0
[8] Available at: https://www.ombudsman.europa.eu/en/doc/correspondence/en/194374
[9] EU Strategy for the Rights of Persons with Disabilities 2021-2030, available at: https://employment-social-affairs.ec.europa.eu/policies-and-activities/social-protection-social-inclusion/persons-disabilities/union-equality-strategy-rights-persons-disabilities-2021-2030_en
[10] Namely tuberculosis, poliomyelitis, cancer, and mental illness.
[11] Commission Decision C(2020) 3002 final.
[12] The Commission was asked to comment on the three following suggestions for improvement: (1) The Commission should publish a non-exhaustive list of assistive devices which are reimbursable under the GIPs. (4) The Commission should ensure, where it is not already happening, that special training on how to deal with disability is part of the induction programme for its staff working on related issues, as well as for staff at management level. (5) The Commission should establish regular contacts with the associations of EU staff members with disabilities, or who have family members with disabilities, in order to receive feedback on the day-to-day application of the JSIS and of the social schemes for persons with disabilities. The Commission should also consult these associations in a meaningful, timely and structured way in the development and implementation of legislation and policies concerning them.
[13] Article 25(e) of the UNCRPD, available at: https://www.un.org/disabilities/documents/convention/convoptprot-e.pdf
[14] Ombudsman recommendation in OI/4/2016/EA, para 32-34 in particular, available at: https://www.ombudsman.europa.eu/en/recommendation/en/99578
[15] See for instance Case F-23/10, Allen v Commission, para 79: https://curia.europa.eu/juris/liste.jsf?num=F-23/10&language=EN ; or, more recently, T-685/21, IR v Commission, para 61-62: https://curia.europa.eu/juris/liste.jsf?language=en&td=ALL&num=T-685/21
[16] Judgment of the Court of 10 January 2006 in case C‑344/04, IATA and ELFAA, para 95, available at: https://curia.europa.eu/juris/liste.jsf?language=en&num=c-344/04
[17] Such as required under Article 25(d) of the UNCRPD, available at : https://www.un.org/disabilities/documents/convention/convoptprot-e.pdf
[18] The issue of available data to assess concretely the inclusion of persons with disabilities in the EU workforce has also been pointed in a recent report from the European Court of Auditors, ‘Supporting persons with disabilities. Practical impact of EU action is limited’, in particular para 61-69 and 92, available at: https://www.eca.europa.eu/ECAPublications/SR-2023-20/SR-2023-20_EN.pdf
[19] Article 31 of the UNCRPD, available at: https://www.un.org/disabilities/documents/convention/convoptprot-e.pdf