- EN English
Decision in case 139/2015/PMC concerning the European Anti-Fraud Office's (OLAF) processing of personal data
Decision
Case 139/2015/PMC - Opened on Monday | 09 February 2015 - Decision on Monday | 11 July 2016 - Institution concerned European Anti-Fraud Office ( No maladministration found , Settled by the institution , No further inquiries justified ) - Country Germany
The complaint concerned OLAF's allegedly unlawful processing of the complainant's personal data.
The Ombudsman found that OLAF took steps to correct an error regarding the complainant’s personal data. She also found that it had not committed maladministration in relation to the transfer of the complainant's personal data, which had been done by the European Commission and not by OLAF.
Because the European Data Protection Supervisor gave a decision in April 2015 regarding OLAF's retention policy on personal data of applicants for access to documents and considers it disproporationate, the Ombudsman did not find it appropriate to inquire further into OLAF’s data retention policy.
The background to the complaint
1. The complaint concerns the allegation that OLAF had contacted what it thought to be the complainant’s employer, a German university. It did so because it wished to verify his identity and what his profession was[1].
2. The complainant was not happy that OLAF had contacted a university to which he had no connection whatsoever. He therefore complained to the Ombudsman about this issue. He made one complaint but against two bodies (OLAF and the European Commission). For purposes of her inquiries, the Ombudsman has registered two complaints - the present complaint against OLAF and a similar complaint against the Commission[2].
The inquiry
3. The Ombudsman opened an inquiry into the allegation that OLAF had unlawfully processed the complainant's personal data.
4. In the course of the inquiry, the Ombudsman received the opinion of OLAF on the complaint and, subsequently, the comments of the complainant in response to OLAF's opinion.
Allegation of unlawful processing of the complainant's personal data
Arguments presented to the Ombudsman
5. The complainant argued that OLAF had a) incorrectly registered information about his professional activity, b) transferred his personal data to a third party without his consent, and c) retained personal data in its database for a disproportionate period of time.
6. In its opinion, OLAF stated that it had entered in its database information about the complainant having professional links to a German university. This was probably done due to a clerical error. OLAF regretted any inconvenience caused to the complainant and stated that it has deleted the information.
7. OLAF denied having transferred the complainant's personal data to the university.
8. Regarding the allegedly disproportionate data retention period, OLAF explained that requests for access to documents related to OLAF investigations are kept for 15 years in the relevant case file in its database. OLAF stated that the complainant had submitted a complaint to the European Data Protection Supervisor (EDPS) regarding this particular issue. A decision was still pending at that stage[3].
9. In his observations, the complainant argued that by failing to verify whether its records were accurate and correct, OLAF had violated its duty of care. He also forwarded to the Ombudsman a letter sent to him by the Commission, dated 4 February 2014, in which the Commission stated that it had revealed his name to the university[4].
10. The complainant maintained that OLAF's maximum retention period of 15 years is disproportionate. He provided a copy of the EDPS' decision, on his complaint regarding the retention period, which had become available in the meantime.
The Ombudsman's assessment
11. It is likely that the incorrect information about the complainant working for a German university was put into the database as a result of a clerical mistake by OLAF. Given that OLAF has regretted the mistake and corrected the data, the Ombudsman considers this aspect of the complainant's allegation to have been resolved.
12. OLAF stated that it had not transferred the complainant's personal data, that is, his name, to the German university where it thought he was working. The Commission's letter of 4 February 2014 to the complainant[5] shows that it was the Commission, and not OLAF, which had disclosed the complainant's name to the university[6]. Hence, there is nothing to indicate that OLAF comitted maladministration concerning this aspect of the complaint.
13. Concerning the allegedly disproportionate data retention period of personal data, the Ombudsman notes that the EDPS has concluded that OLAF's retention period is disproportionate. The Memorandum of Understanding between the Ombudsman and the EDPS[7] sets out that unnecessary duplication of procedures and diverging approaches should be avoided. The Ombudsman therefore considers that it would not be appropriate for her to make her own finding on this aspect of the complaint, which has already been dealt with by the EDPS. The Ombudsman will therefore not inquire further into this matter.
Conclusion
On the basis of the inquiry into this complaint, the Ombudsman closes it with the following findings:
By rectifying the incorrectly registered information about the complainant's professional activity in the relevant database, this aspect of the complainant's grievance has been resolved.
There was no maladministration by OLAF in relation to the transfer of the complainant's personal data.
The Ombudsman does not consider it appropriate to inquire further into the issue of OLAF's retention period for personal data.
The complainant and OLAF will be informed of this decision.
Emily O'Reilly
Strasbourg, 11/07/2016
[1] The institution requested this data from applicants in order to process their requests for public access to documents.
[2] Case 2063/2014/PMC.
[3] EDPS case 2012-1026.
[4] This letter was also sent to the complainant by the Commission in the context of the Ombudsman's inquiry into the complaint 2310/2013/JAS.
[5] The letter - which is written in German - explicitly says that "concerning your professional activity, you indicated to OLAF that you were working for the Institute of International and European Law of [a German university]. However, this Institute does not exist under the said name. Following our [i.e. the Commission's] request, the university noted that it did not have any employee with the name ['Mr X']", that is, with the complainant's name.
[6] In her decision in case 2063/2014/PMC against the Commission, the Ombudsman concluded that disclosing the complainant's name to the university without a valid justification was serious maladministration.
[7] Memorandum of understanding between the European Ombudsman and the European Data Protection Supervisor, OJ 2007 C 27, p. 21