# Decision on the European Commission's refusal to give public access to the minutes of meetings of the EU Regional Task Force Greece (case 2237/2024/AML)
- Author: European Ombudsman
- Date: 2026-11-18T10:00+01:00[Europe/Paris]
- [URL](https://www.ombudsman.europa.eu/en/decision/en/237072)
---
> The case concerned the refusal of the European Commission to provide full public access to 34 documents comprising the minutes of meetings of the EU Regional Task Force (EURTF) on Greece that took place between 2016 and 2021. In refusing to give full public access, the Commission relied on two exceptions set out in the EU legislation on public access to documents (Regulation 1049/2001), that is, the need to protect the public interest as regards public security and international relations.
>
> Based on the inspection of the documents at issue and considering the delay by the Commission in processing the access request, the Ombudsman was not convinced by the Commission's assessment of the sensitivity of the documents or their redacted parts at issue. The Ombudsman made a proposal for a solution, in which she asked the Commission to reassess 15 of the documents, taking into account the passage of time and possible changes in circumstances, with a view to granting wider partial access.
>
> The Commission refused the Ombudsman's proposal for a solution. It declined to grant wider access and stated that it would be better for the complainant to submit a new request for public access to documents.
>
> Maintaining her view that wider partial access should have been granted, the Ombudsman closed the inquiry with a finding of maladministration. The Ombudsman further recalled that complainants have a fundamental right to turn to her Office, which is one of the two formal redress mechanisms foreseen under Regulation 1049/2001. As such, if she invites an institution to reassess its position, the institution should do so rather than inviting the complainant to submit a new access request.
>
Background to the complaint
---------------------------
**1.** In 2015, the European Commission presented its European agenda on migration.[\[1\]](#_ftn1){#_ftnref1} The Agenda introduced the 'hotspot approach', whereby the EU and its Member States work together to manage migration at the external borders of the EU. EU Regional Task Forces (EURTF) were subsequently set up to facilitate operational cooperation and information exchange in hotspot areas. Participants in EURTF meetings included representatives of the Commission, EU Agencies, and in some instances national authorities.
**2.** In September 2021, the complainant, a researcher, made a request for public access to documents[\[2\]](#_ftn2){#_ftnref2} held by the Commission. The request covered *'Minutes from the EU Regional Task Force meetings in Greece 1) From June 2015 until September 2016; 2) From May 2018 until December 2018; and 3) From April 2020 until September 2021'*.
**3.** In December 2021, the Commission adopted its initial decision, in which it identified 34 documents[\[3\]](#_ftn3){#_ftnref3} as falling within the scope of the request, and refused access to all of them.
**4.**The complainant asked the Commission to review its decision in January 2022 (by making a 'confirmatory application').
**5.** In February 2023, the Commission adopted its confirmatory decision on the access request. In its decision, the Commission provided partial access to 27 documents (documents 1-28) and refused access to the seven remaining documents in their entirety. In doing so, it relied to the need to protect the public interest as regards public security and international relations,[\[4\]](#_ftn4){#_ftnref4} and the protection of personal data.[\[5\]](#_ftn5){#_ftnref5}
**6.**On 3 December 2024, dissatisfied with the Commission's decision, the complainant turned to the Ombudsman.
The inquiry
-----------
**7.**The Ombudsman opened an inquiry into the Commission's refusal to give (wider) public access to the minutes of meetings of the EURTF Greece. As the complainant did not challenge the redaction of information based on the need to protect personal data, this was not part of the Ombudsman's inquiry.
**8.**During the inquiry, the Ombudsman inquiry team inspected the documents at issue, as well as the documents including the third-party consultations conducted by the Commission in relation to the access request.
**9.**The Ombudsman inquiry team met with Commission representatives in order to clarify a number of questions following the inspection of the documents, and received the complainant's comments on the meeting report.
**10.**The Commission did not provide an additional written reply on the complaint, as it considered that its position had been set out in the confirmatory decision.
### Arguments presented to the Ombudsman
**11.** **The complainant** considered that the Commission had made an excessive and manifestly erroneous use of the exceptions invoked.
**12.**Specifically, in her confirmatory application, the complainant argued that the Commission had failed to sufficiently explain how it carried out an individual assessment of each document and how disclosure of the documents concerned or their redacted parts could undermine the protected interests invoked in a specific and non-hypothetical manner. In her view, the sensitivity of the documents was questionable considering the time that had passed since the first meeting at issue took place. The complainant further took issue with how the Commission dealt with the objections of third parties to the disclosure of the documents or their redacted parts, arguing that it was unclear if the Commission had independently assessed those objections, and recalling that they should be overridden if they conflicted with EU legislation and case law on transparency. Finally, the complainant claimed that the Commission had been inconsistent in its approach, as it granted very wide access to a similar document in an earlier public access request.
**13.** During the inquiry, the complainant further expanded on those arguments. In particular, she argued that it would be visible from the partially released documents that EURTF meetings contain information that is not always security-related but also humanitarian in nature (seasonal maintenance, interpretation services or medical services). That information, moreover, would be specific to facilities that have now been entirely dismantled and thus the content is '*historical'*. Similarly, the relations with the third country mentioned in the documents would have considerably evolved. In her view, even if at the time of drafting part of this information may have been covered by the exceptions invoked, the circumstances would have changed so much that, at the time of the confirmatory decision, there was no serious or actual risk related to disclosure. The complainant further reiterated her concerns as regards the Commission's handling of the objections of third parties.
**14.** **The Commission,** in its confirmatory decision, argued that it was not possible to give wider access to the requested documents or their redacted parts, as they contained **operational information related to border management and criminal activities,** which, if disclosed, would put at risk ongoing operations conducted by law enforcement authorities (documents from 2020-2021), and/or broader EU efforts in tackling cross-border crime and unauthorised border crossings. The documents would also contain information about shortcomings and non-public details on the cooperation with a third country, which, if disclosed, **would undermine Greece's national interests and** **international relations with the third country concerned.**
**15.** During the inquiry, the Commission further explained that the cooperation within the EURTF is founded on trust, and that disclosing these exchanges could have a chilling effect, in turn putting at risk the Commission's cooperation on migration in future. As a consequence, the Commission consulted the participants in EURTF meetings, who opposed disclosure to various extents.[\[6\]](#_ftn6){#_ftnref6} The Commission emphasised that it had carried out a full assessment of harm, and that it duly took into account the passage of time in that process. Whilst the documents requested or their redacted parts date from several years ago, they nonetheless relate to ongoing discussions on migration management. The Commission identified four main risks if the documents were to be further disclosed.[\[7\]](#_ftn7){#_ftnref7} Commission representatives explained that even if some facts or information may appear to be already publicly known, the documents contain more details, and the vast majority of information is not publicly available.
**16.** Finally, the Commission noted that, while it is true that in a previous application concerning a similar document,[\[8\]](#_ftn8){#_ftnref8} no consultation took place and the document was disclosed almost in full (with the exception of personal data), this did not mean that the same should apply to the documents at issue.
### The Ombudsman's proposal for a solution
**17.**Based on the inspection of the documents at issue, the Ombudsman did not take issue with the redactions in documents 1-20 dating from 2016 (19 documents), which were limited and did not indicate a manifest error of assessment. However, she was not convinced that the Commission had adequately assessed the sensitivity of the remaining documents or their redacted parts and thus the harm in granting the widest access possible to them. This was especially the case considering the delay of the Commission in processing the access request.
**18.**Specifically, she noted that the Commission's explanations as regards the sensitivity of the 15 remaining documents or their redacted parts, dating from 2018, 2020, and 2021, largely relied on the fact that these documents would cover ongoing operations, and/or would contain information about discussions within the EURTF that have remained broadly the same.
**19.** The Ombudsman also took account of the fact that when the access request was registered[\[9\]](#_ftn9){#_ftnref9} some meetings of the EURTF were indeed recent, but that this was no longer the case when the Commission adopted its confirmatory decision nearly a year and a half later. Thus, the 'ongoing' nature of the operations at issue, which the Commission relied on to justify the non-disclosure of documents dating from 2020-2021, appeared questionable. The Ombudsman further noted that the third party, which had most opposed disclosure of some of the documents or their redacted parts on the basis that they related to 'ongoing operations', was not consulted again at confirmatory stage, even though it may have had a different view on disclosure at that point in time. Moreover, the Ombudsman noted that the documents appeared to contain other information that was not related to such ongoing operations, and that wide access had been provided to similar information in the documents partially disclosed by the Commission in the same access request (and full access in another request). Finally, the Ombudsman underlined that many of the redactions in the documents from 2018 appeared to contain possibly outdated and non-actionable information related to facilities that did not exist anymore, as well as other outdated factual information.
**20.**In light of this, the Ombudsman considered that the Commission had not adequately taken into account the passage of time and the change in circumstances when handling this access request. She proposed that the Commission reassess the documents from 2018, 2020 and 2021 with a view to granting wider (partial) access. However, if the Commission maintains its view that certain parts of the documents still needed to be withheld, it should provide the Ombudsman with further explanations. In this context, she encouraged the Commission to consult again the participants to EURTF meetings when replying to her proposal.
**21.** In its reply,[\[10\]](#_ftn10){#_ftnref10} **the Commission** claimed that the complaint was '*lodged by a third party* ', different '*from the one who submitted the application \[for public access to documents\]* ', and that the arguments raised in the complaint '*were never part of the original administrative process'* . The Commission noted that the complaint was lodged almost two years after the confirmatory decision, and with the passage of time, the circumstances and the sensitivity of the documents may have evolved. In light of these different elements, the Commission stated that '*in the interest of procedural fairness and administrative efficiency, it remains open for the complainant to submit an initial application \[for access to documents\]'.*
**22.**As regards the contents of the solution proposal, the Commission welcomed what it considered to be the Ombudsman's conclusion that there was no manifest error of assessment regarding most of the documents, and thus that its approach was balanced and proportionate. The Commission subsequently refused the Ombudsman's proposal. In particular, the Commission maintained its view that it had granted the widest possible access to the documents concerned at the time of the adoption of its confirmatory decision. It considered that it had adequately taken into consideration the passage of time, as illustrated by its decision to grant partial access to the documents at issue. The Commission argued that the Ombudsman did not dispute that the contents of the documents related to interests protected by the absolute exceptions relied upon, and reiterated the explanations provided during the meeting with the Ombudsman inquiry team as regards the harm to the interests invoked.
**23.**Finally, the Commission considered that it had appropriately consulted EURTF participants before the adoption of its confirmatory decision, and that no further consultation was necessary, as the position of the Greek authorities was unequivocal and based on concerns that had not diminished over time.
**24.** **The complainant,**in the comments on the solution reply, expressed profound disappointment that the Commission has decided not to follow what she considered to be a reasonable solution proposal.
**25.**As regards the procedural aspects, the complainant noted that the Ombudsman's complaint procedure allows complaints to be submitted on behalf of an applicant. In this case, the complaint was lodged in collaboration with, and with the consent of, the requester. It did not constitute an attempt by an unrelated third party to introduce a new dispute concerning the documents. The complainant emphasised that her central arguments had already been raised at confirmatory stage, and that, at this point in time, the requester cannot be expected to anticipate the future arguments of the institution.
**26.**The complainant further underlined that the Commission's emphasis on the time it took to submit the complaint overlooked the Commission's own responsibility for the delay in this case -- namely, the 13 months it took to provide a confirmatory decision. The complainant questioned invoking the passage of time as a procedural argument against reassessing the sensitivity of the documents, when a significant part of that passage of time resulted from the Commission's own delays. In addition, and as the complaint was submitted within the time limits foreseen under the Ombudsman's procedure, she emphasised that there was no procedural irregularity that would justify the refusal to address the substance of the complaint.
**27.**On the substance of the Commission's reply, the complainant stated that the Commission had mischaracterised the Ombudsman's findings, as requesting the reassessment of 15 documents cannot be interpreted as endorsing the Commission's approach as 'balanced' and 'proportionate'. The complainant referred back to the arguments submitted during the inquiry, adding that, as regards the opposition of the Greek authorities, it is well-established that a Member State's opposition to disclosure cannot, in itself, determine the outcome of an access to documents request. The complainant thus called upon the Commission to engage with the Ombudsman's proposal instead of simply accepting the opposition of Greek authorities, and to encourage Member States to respect EU law on transparency, particularly where documents concern the operation of EU-level mechanisms.
**28.**To conclude, the complainant took the view that the Commission had dismissed the Ombudsman's solution proposal and put forward unfounded procedural objections. Requiring the submission of a new access request would effectively entail restarting a process that began several years ago, despite the fact that the specific documents warranting reassessment have now been identified. In light of this, the complainant invited the Ombudsman to conclude the inquiry with a finding of maladministration.
The Ombudsman's assessment after the proposal for a solution
------------------------------------------------------------
#### Procedural aspects
**29.**The Ombudsman will address first the two procedural points raised by the Commission: (i) its statement that the complainant is a third party to the complaint, and that the arguments have not been raised beforehand with the Commission; (ii) by emphasising the length of time between the confirmatory decision and the complaint to the Ombudsman, the Commission appears to question the utility of a solution proposal as an inquiry tool, rather referring to the option for the complainant to submit a new public access request.
**30.**As regards the first consideration above, the Commission appears to confuse the complainant with her representative. However, and as noted by the complainant, the right to be represented when submitting a complaint to the Ombudsman by a third party does not alter their identity as a complainant, nor should it impact on how the Commission then deals with the Ombudsman's inquiry, for instance by suggesting that the complainant (or her representative) now makes a new access request.
**31.**Moreover, and contrary to the Commission's claim, the Ombudsman agrees with the complainant that her core arguments have remained constant since her confirmatory application and subsequently in her complaint. This is well illustrated in the 'Arguments' section of this decision. The Commission addressed those arguments in its confirmatory decision and was afforded a further opportunity to comment on the complaint when the inquiry was opened, but declined to do so.
**32.**As regards the second point raised by the Commission, the Ombudsman recalls that complainants, based on the Treaties and the Charter, have a fundamental right to submit a complaint to her Office. Such complaints must be made within two years of the date on which the facts on which it is based came to their attention. In addition, the Ombudsman is one of the two redress mechanisms foreseen under Regulation 1049/2001. Thus, the temporal scope of two years also applies to complaints concerning public access to documents, and an institution's refusal to grant access, whether in whole or in part to the documents requested. As such, if the Ombudsman invites an institution to reassess its position, that institution should do so rather than inviting the complainant to submit a new access request. As correctly pointed out by the complainant, a considerable part of the delay in this case is attributable to the Commission's failure to timely adopt a confirmatory decision, which it only did after a period of 13 months.
#### On the substance of the reply
**33.**As regards the substance of the Commission's reply, the Ombudsman regrets that the Commission, in essence, has refused to engage with her proposal for a solution.
**34.**Specifically, the Ombudsman's solution proposal was that the Commission should reassess certain selected documents with a view to granting wider access to them, or in the alternative, if this was not possible to safeguard the protected interest, provide greater reasoning as to why certain parts still needed to be withheld up to present day. As part of that process, the Ombudsman encouraged the Commission to take into account a number of observations she had made in relation to the sensitivity of the documents and the passage of time, and to consult EURTF participants again on the possibility of wider disclosure.
**35.** As a preliminary remark, and contrary to the Commission's statement that the Ombudsman did not dispute the application of the exceptions invoked, it must be recalled that the premise for the proposal was that the Ombudsman was not convinced by the assessment of harm as regards the sensitivity of the documents or their redacted parts. The wording of the solution proposal reflects this throughout. This is also evidenced in the operative part of the proposal, where the Commission was called upon to *reassess the documents at issue with a view of granting wider partial access*.
**36.**Beyond this, the Commission has not given effect to any of the aspects of the Ombudsman's proposal. Specifically, it does not seem to have conducted the reassessment of the documents proposed by the Ombudsman. Nor has it provided any new fact or argument in favour of non-disclosure beyond what had already been presented during the inquiry, and which had not sufficed to convince the Ombudsman. The reply, moreover, does not address the specific concerns raised by the Ombudsman as regards the sensitivity of the documents, such as the fact that:
a)It was unclear whether the 'ongoing operations' mentioned by the Commission as justifying non-disclosure were indeed still ongoing at the time of the confirmatory decision;
b)The documents appeared in any case to contain information other than related to those operations;
c)Full or wide disclosure of such other information had been possible in other documents (both in the same and in a different access requests), and;
d)Redactions seemed to cover factual elements and information that appeared outdated and non-actionable and thus unlikely to be sensitive at the time of the confirmatory decision.
**37.**On that last aspect, the Ombudsman considers that it is still unclear how factual information relating to daily life in facilities that have since then been entirely dismantled, could be covered by one of the exceptions invoked by the Commission. This is especially the case for information relating to living conditions (applicable several years ago), repairs or maintenance (of buildings that have been destroyed) and nationalities of residents (evolving on a monthly basis and subject to publication by international organisations).
**38.**It is also clear that the third parties concerned, and in particular those which had not been consulted in the context of the confirmatory decision, were not consulted again. This is despite the observation of the Ombudsman that especially one party which had objected to disclosure on the basis that its operations were 'ongoing' may have had a different view on the access request that could have usefully informed the Commission's (re)assessment.
**39.** This refusal to give any effect to the Ombudsman's solution proposal is all the more concerning as it goes against the established practice of the Commission to reassess *documents* (not just the *confirmatory decision*) following a proposal by the Ombudsman.
**40.** In that context, the Ombudsman maintains her view that the documents or their parts withheld by the Commission were not sensitive *throughou* t. She disagrees with the Commission's position that the widest access possible was granted, both at the time of the confirmatory decision and up to present day. In her view, it is not possible to reconcile the Commission's description of the information not released (especially concerning alleged operational information related to border management and criminal activities), and the actual content of (parts of) the requested documents. The Commission has not provided any further substantive reasoning that would enable the Ombudsman to understand why that is the case. Therefore, and as she is unconvinced that all excerpts concerned would, considering their nature, date and content, be so sensitive that their disclosure would actually and specifically undermine the interests invoked, the Ombudsman considers that not granting (wider) partial access to those parts **constitutes maladministration.**
**41.**It is clear that the Commission does not intend to change its position on the matter. Therefore, a recommendation would serve no useful purpose.
Conclusion(s)
-------------
Based on the inquiry, the Ombudsman closes this case with the following finding:
**The European Commission's failure to grant (wider) partial access to the documents at issue constituted maladministration.**
The complainant and the Commission will be informed of this decision**.**
Teresa Anjinho
European Ombudsman
<br />
Strasbourg, 16/11/2026
[\[1\]](#_ftnref1){#_ftn1} COM(2015) 240 final, available at: <https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=celex:52015DC0240>
[\[2\]](#_ftnref2){#_ftn2} Under Regulation (EC) No 1049/2001 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 30 May 2001 regarding public access to European Parliament, Council and Commission documents ("Regulation 1049/2001"), available at: <https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2001/1049/oj/eng>
[\[3\]](#_ftnref3){#_ftn3} The documents were erroneously numbered as 1-35 (instead of 1-34), due to a clerical error. For the sake of clarity, the same numbering is used in this solution proposal. In the Ombudsman's inquiry, the documents were divided into three categories depending on the year of the meeting. Documents 1-20 concerned meetings from 2016, documents 21-28 concerned meetings from 2018 and documents 29-35 concerned meetings from 2020 and 2021.
[\[4\]](#_ftnref4){#_ftn4} Respectively Article 4(1)(a), first and third indent of Regulation 1049/2001.
[\[5\]](#_ftnref5){#_ftn5} Article 4(1)(b) of Regulation 1049/2001.
[\[6\]](#_ftnref6){#_ftn6} Specifically, the Greek authorities opposed disclosure on the basis of the exceptions protecting public security and international relations, while Europol requested the redaction of its contributions on the basis of the public security exception. Frontex asked for non-disclosure of parts of documents 1-31 and of the entirety of documents 32-35. Both the Greek authorities and Europol were consulted at the initial and confirmatory stages, whereas Frontex was consulted at the initial stage.
[\[7\]](#_ftnref7){#_ftn7} See meeting report, available at: <https://www.ombudsman.europa.eu/doc/inspection-report/237024>
[\[8\]](#_ftnref8){#_ftn8} Minutes of the 67th meeting of the EURTF, 5 March 2020.
[\[9\]](#_ftnref9){#_ftn9} See paragraph 2.
[\[10\]](#_ftnref10){#_ftn10} Solution reply, available at: <https://www.ombudsman.europa.eu/solution/237023>