FOR PREVIEWING & TESTING PURPOSES ONLY.
This notification will disappear once the page will be published.
This link is available for less than 30 minutes.
  • Easy to read
  • Text size

You have a complaint against an EU institution or body?

Current language: 
  • English
Available languages: 

Decision on how the European Commission handled an infringement complaint concerning Dutch legislation on light electric vehicles (case 667/2024/AML)

The case concerned how the European Commission handled an infringement complaint against the Netherlands, regarding Dutch legislation on light electric vehicles. The complainant was concerned that he had not had any update from the Commission in over two years.

While the inquiry was ongoing, the Commission closed the case. However, the Ombudsman found that the Commission failed to demonstrate that it had handled the case actively and diligently. In particular, the Commission failed to provide a convincing justification for the delay in dealing with a case which, considering the reasons given to close the case, should have been clear from the outset. The Ombudsman considered that this constituted maladministration. However, as the Commission has since then acknowledged and apologised for the delay when closing the case, and has in parallel committed to improving its communication with complainants, the Ombudsman considered that no purpose would be served by making a recommendation.

Background to the complaint

1. In October 2021, the complainant, an EU citizen residing in the Netherlands, submitted an infringement complaint to the Commission concerning Dutch legislation on light electric vehicles[1]. The complainant alleged that the Netherlands had introduced additional technical requirements for these vehicles, meaning people in the Netherlands are not able to use vehicles otherwise compliant with EU norms.[2] In his view, this was not in line with EU law.

2. The Commission registered the complaint in November 2021. In December 2021, it informed the complainant that his complaint was still being analysed as it raised broader issues. Following this, the complainant did not receive any update of the state of play of his complaint, despite sending a reminder to the Commission in February 2022.

3. On 7 April 2024, dissatisfied with the situation, the complainant turned to the Ombudsman.

The inquiry

4. The Ombudsman opened an inquiry into how the Commission dealt with the infringement complaint, in particular the time it took to deal with it.

5. In the course of the inquiry, the Ombudsman received the reply of the Commission on the matter. The Ombudsman inquiry team also inspected the Commission’s file on the infringement complaint.

6. The Ombudsman then received the comments of the complainant on the Commission’s reply and the inspection report.

7. While the case was ongoing, the Commission informed the complainant of its intention to close the case, and did so in June 2024.

Arguments presented to the Ombudsman

8. The complainant claimed, in essence, that the Commission should have taken action on his complaint to ensure that people in the Netherlands can use these light electric vehicles.

9. The Commission acknowledged the delay, which it said was due to workload, and apologised to the complainant. As regards the absence of updates to the complainant since 2021, the Commission explained that this was due to an IT error.

10. As regards its assessment of the infringement complaint, the Commission stated that it had an exchange with Dutch authorities on the matter. Following this, in May 2024, it informed the complainant of its intention to close his complaint, as it had not identified any breach of EU law. This was because parts of the concerns raised by the complainant related to provisions of a draft framework only, and thus could not infringe EU law. In addition, as regards the existing Dutch law, the Commission explained that EU legislation does not cover safety requirements for the road use of the categories of light electric vehicles the complainant was most concerned with.[3] Deciding on such requirements thus falls within the competence of Member States.

11. After having received the complainant’s reply on its pre-closure letter, the Commission closed the case in June 2024.

The Ombudsman's assessment

12. The Commission enjoys wide discretion when dealing with infringement complaints.[4] The Ombudsman’s role in this area thus concerns the administrative and procedural handling of infringement cases by the Commission. This includes ensuring that the Commission exercises its discretion in accordance with its own rules.[5]

13. In its Communication ‘EU law: Better results through better application’, the Commission has set out an indicative time limit of one year from the registration of an infringement complaint to decide whether to issue a letter of formal notice to the Member State concerned or to close the case. Where this time limit is exceeded, the Commission has committed to inform the complainant in writing. The Ombudsman has consistently found that the principles of good administration require the Commission to provide specific and convincing reasons for the additional time needed to deal with the case.[6] Otherwise, this may constitute maladministration.[7]

14. In this case, the reasons provided by the Commission to close the case (in particular the fact that the provisions the complainant seemed most concerned about had never been adopted) indicate that the complaint was, from the outset, unlikely to give rise to a finding that EU law had been infringed.  

15. In light of this, it is not clear why it took the Commission more than 30 months to establish these facts and to close the case. The Commission’s reply to the Ombudsman does not offer a convincing and specific reason for this delay. On the contrary, the inspection of the Commission’s file by the Ombudsman inquiry team showed that the Commission did not appear to have taken any action on the infringement complaint between December 2021 and May 2024.

16. While the Ombudsman acknowledges the Commission’s swift action on the infringement complaint after an inquiry was opened in April 2024, she recalls that the Commission’s wide margin of discretion does not mean that the Commission can abstain from dealing with infringement complaints for a long period of time.[8] In this case, the Commission did not complete its assessment of the infringement complaint in a reasonable time, and did not demonstrate that it was active and diligent in dealing with the case. This constitutes maladministration.

17. Moreover, it is regrettable that the complainant received only one standard holding reply in December 2021, and no additional updates until the case was pre-closed more than two years later - despite having sent a reminder to the Commission in the meantime. This is clearly not good administration.

18. That said, as the Commission acknowledged and apologised for the delay and closed the case, and has in parallel committed to improving its communication with complainants,[9] there would be no purpose served by the Ombudsman making a recommendation in this case. The Ombudsman refers the Commission to her recent closing note in SI/6/2024/JN, in which she tackled both the question of delays and of communication with complainants.

Conclusion

Based on the inquiry, the Ombudsman closes this case with the following finding:

There was maladministration in how the Commission handled the infringement complaint.

The complainant and the Commission will be informed of this decision.

Teresa Anjinho
European Ombudsman


Strasbourg, 03/06/2025

 

[1] Light electric vehicles are innovative electric vehicles such as e-scooters, mono-wheels, or cargo and carrier e-bikes.

[2] In his exchanges with the Commission, the complainant referred in particular to requirements set out in Directive 2006/42/EC on machinery (available at: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/dir/2006/42/oj/eng) and Regulation 168/2013 on the approval and market surveillance of two- or three-wheel vehicles and quadricycles (available at: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2013/168/oj/eng)

[3] More specifically, the Commission explained that a difference must be made between electric vehicles falling under the EU legislation on approval and market surveillance of two- or three-wheel vehicles and quadricycles (such as certain bikes), and those that do not (mono-wheels, e-scooters, and other types of bikes). For the first category, Dutch legislation complies with EU legislation on approval and market surveillance. For the second category, which the complainant is most concerned about, although Member States must not impede the placing of these vehicles on the market if they are compliant with EU legislation on machinery (Directive 2006/42/EC, to be replaced by Regulation 2023/1230 in 2027), EU legislation does not cover their road use and related requirements.

[4] Judgment of the Court of 14 February 1989, Starfruit v Commission, case 247/87, available at: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX:61987CJ0247

[5] In particular the Commission Communication ‘EU law: Better results through better application’, 2017/C 18/02, available at: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/PDF/?uri=CELEX:52017XC0119(01)

[6] See case 2029/2022/EIS, para 18, available at: https://www.ombudsman.europa.eu/en/decision/en/179452 ; as well as case 425/2017/ANA, para 28, available at: https://www.ombudsman.europa.eu/en/decision/en/90387

[7] Case 2029/2022/EIS, para 17, quoted above; as well as case 369/2018/JAP, para 19, available at: https://www.ombudsman.europa.eu/en/decision/en/119020

[8] Case 1171/2023/JN, para 28, available at: https://www.ombudsman.europa.eu/en/decision/en/186479

[9] Closing note in case SI/6/2024/JN, in particular para 9-12, available at: https://www.ombudsman.europa.eu/en/doc/closing-note/en/197101