FOR PREVIEWING & TESTING PURPOSES ONLY.
This notification will disappear once the page will be published.
This link is available for less than 30 minutes.
  • Easy to read
  • Text size

You have a complaint against an EU institution or body?

Current language: 
  • English
Available languages: 

Decision of the European Ombudsman closing his inquiry into complaint 2127/2010/AN against the European Commission

The background to the complaint

1. The complainant worked for the fourth pillar ('Pillar IV') of the United Nations Interim Administration Mission in Kosovo (UNMIK).

2. UNMIK was established by the United Nations Security Council Resolution 1244 of 10 June 1999[1]. It was organised into four action areas (pillars) led by different international expert entities. Pillar IV was entrusted with providing the legal, institutional and policy framework for the economic reconstruction, recovery and development of Kosovo[2]. It was headed by the Deputy Special Representative of the Secretary-General of the United Nations (DSRSG), who was appointed by the latter and was responsible for implementing the activities of the pillar through the administration of its operational budget.

3. As foreseen by Council Regulation (EC) 1080/2000[3], and subsequently by Council Regulation 1085/2006[4], Pillar IV was entirely funded by the European Commission, which financed its running costs between 1999 and 2008, including its liquidation. The funding was made available through consecutive contribution agreements.

4. In 2005, the Commission and the DSRSG agreed that Pillar IV had achieved the majority of its objectives, and they therefore organised its winding down. In 2007, the Commission decided to cease its funding, and Pillar IV started to reduce its activities and to prepare for their transfer to the Kosovar Provisional Institutions of Self Government. Pillar IV eventually ceased its activities on 30 June 2008.

5. With a view to avoiding key staff leaving their posts within Pillar IV too early, and thus to ensure a smooth transition, the Commission and the Pillar IV management agreed upon a retention scheme.

6. In November 2006, the DSRSG adopted a decision (the 'Retention Bonus Rules'), according to which staff members whose posts were discontinued by the Pillar, and who were not offered an alternative job, would receive a bonus (the 'retention bonus'). The bonus was dependent on funding being available from the Commission. Moreover, in order to be eligible for the retention bonus, staff members had to have been employed for at least one year prior to the discontinuation of their post (the 'eligibility criteria'). In 2007, the Commission adopted a decision concerning the financing of the Fourth Pillar of UNMIK[5] (the 'Financing Decision'). The latter foresaw that a retention bonus would be granted to staff who remained in their posts until asked to leave.

7. The same year, the authorities of Pillar IV decided to grant the retention bonus to staff members who, at the end of 2007, had already worked for the Pillar for at least one year (the 'Contested Decision'). Given that the complainant did not fulfil that condition because he began working for the Pillar on [...], he did not receive the bonus. The complainant approached his hierarchy in the Fourth Pillar and complained that the Contested Decision was not lawful. His requests were rejected.

8. On [...], the complainant turned to the Commission and requested it to annul the Contested Decision and to grant him the bonus. In his letter, the complainant put forward that the Contested Decision was unlawful because, on the one hand, it added a new rule to the Retention Bonus Rules, namely, that the one-year experience criterion had to be fulfilled at the end of 2007. This was also in breach of his work contract, which stated that he might be eligible to receive a retention bonus if he were to satisfy the eligibility criteria outlined in the Retention Bonus Rules. On the other hand, the bonus was granted to certain employees whose posts were not discontinued at the end of 2007.

9. The Commission replied on [...]. It informed the complainant that it was not in any way involved in the management of Pillar IV and that the complainant was an employee of UNMIK which signed a work contract with the DSRSG. The Commission therefore concluded that it could not review the Contested Decision taken by the Pillar IV management. Moreover, the Commission mentioned that, although the Financing Decision contained the Commission's agreement for a retention bonus to be granted by Pillar IV, "it did not and could not contain application provisions or criteria for individual granting", which were to be determined by the DSRSG.

10. The complainant was not satisfied with the outcome of these contacts and turned to the Ombudsman.

The subject matter of the inquiry

11. The Ombudsman opened an inquiry into the following allegation:

As regards the payment of retention bonuses, the Commission did not comply with its duty to supervise the use of the funds by the Fourth Pillar of UNMIK.

12. In addition to his above allegation, the complainant claimed that the Commission should revise the Contested Decision and grant him the retention bonus. However, considering that the Commission did not have the power to review a decision taken by the DSRSG, the Ombudsman did not include that claim in his inquiry[6]. Moreover, the Ombudsman informed the complainant that he would not take a stance on the arguments concerning the Pillar IV management's alleged breach of his employment contract. This was because the management's conduct was not within the Ombudsman's mandate.

The inquiry

13. The complainant turned to the Ombudsman on 30 September 2010 and subsequently completed his complaint on 24 and 29 October 2010. The Ombudsman forwarded the complaint to the President of the European Commission on 29 November 2010.

14. On the same date, the Ombudsman asked the President of the Court of Auditors of the European Union whether that institution had audited the use of funds made available to Pillar IV as a result of the Financing Decision. In the affirmative, the Ombudsman asked for the results of the said audit. On 8 December 2010, the Court of Auditors informed the Ombudsman that it had not conducted any audit work concerning the use of those funds.

15. On 18 January 2011, the Ombudsman's representatives inspected the Commission's file on the complaint and took copies of the relevant documents. On 19 January 2011, the Commission submitted clarifications by e-mail concerning certain documents which were examined during the inspection. An inspection report was sent to the complainant and the Commission on 4 February 2011.

16. On 11 March 2011, the Commission submitted its opinion on the complaint, which was forwarded to the complainant with an invitation to submit observations. The complainant submitted observations on 30 April 2011.

The Ombudsman's analysis and conclusions

A. Allegation that the Commission failed to supervise the use of EU funds for the retention bonus

Arguments presented to the Ombudsman

17. In his complaint, the complainant argued that the Commission's negligence allowed EU funds to be misused, in breach of "EU law fundamental principles of fair treatment, good administration, good faith in contractual relations, legal certainty, legitimate expectations, etc." The Commission thus failed to comply with its duty of sound financial management. In the complainant’s view, the Commission did so even though (i) the Fourth Pillar was financed by the Commission, (ii) important expenses of the said fund had to be approved by the Commission, (iii) his salary was transferred to him from a Belgian account that presumably belonged to the Commission and (iv) the paper on which his work contract was printed bore both the logo of the UNMIK and of the EU.

18. In its observations, the Commission stated that it fulfilled its obligations and adequately supervised the Pillar IV activities. It mentioned that, according to the Contribution Agreement[7], the Pillar reported to the European Parliament and the Commission. Its duties included, among others[8], sending quarterly reports to the Commission on the implementation of the policies and detailed reports on the financing, expenditure and staff development. They were a precondition to the payment of the instalments to the Pillar. All these reports were approved by the Commission’s officer in charge, and the Pillar’s accounts were also audited by an independent auditor, who issued "unqualified opinions."

19. Besides these formal verifications, the Commission’s Liaison Office to Kosovo and the Commission’s headquarters were in regular contact with Pillar IV. In general terms, Pillar IV's integrity during its mission was never put into doubt.

20. Moreover, Pillar IV's reports gave no reasons to believe that the funds reserved for the retention scheme were used for other purposes. The Commission did not consider that the general conditions for the payment of the bonus, of which it was aware, were in breach of EU law. It therefore neither had the intention, nor the power to question individual decisions regarding the payment of the bonus. As regards the complainant’s concrete case, the Commission stated that, following his letter dated [...], it contacted the Pillar IV management and received a satisfactory reply. The reply mentioned that the correct procedure was followed and appropriate legal advice was sought.

21. Finally, the Commission reiterated that it was not the complainant's employer because (i) Pillar IV was not a joint management action[9]; (ii) the Commission had no link with the Pillar’s contractors[10], including its employees; and (iii) the Commission was exempt from any kind of liability for Pillar IV actions[11]. In any event, the Commission never made any direct payment to the complainant, and Pillar IV was obliged to use the EU logo on its letterheads, leaflets, premises, etc[12].

22. In his observations, the complainant stated that the Commission did not contradict his argument that the retention bonus was awarded in breach of the conditions established in the Financing Decision. Moreover, he maintained that this was possible because the Commission failed adequately to supervise the use of the funds reserved for the retention bonus. Finally, the complainant emphasised that the EU financed Pillar IV in its entirety, the EU logo appeared everywhere and, in the employment contracts, Pillar IV was described as an "EU Pillar". In his view, this created "legitimate expectations" for the Pillar’s employees that the EU would ensure the respect of general principles of EU law and fundamental rights. Consequently, the Commission should ensure the above and not "hide behind the United Nations".

The Ombudsman's assessment

23. The Ombudsman understands the complainant to believe that the Commission's failure to supervise the use of EU funds by Pillar IV, which, he believes, was in breach of the Financing Decision, allowed Pillar IV to adopt the Contested Decision and pay out the retention bonuses arbitrarily. Indeed, according to Section 6.1 (Audit and financial control) of the Annex to the Financing Decision, "[t]he accounts and operations of all the actions led in the framework of the programme are subject to financial supervision and control from the Commission, including the European Anti-Fraud Office". The Ombudsman opened the present inquiry on the basis of the above provision because, from the correspondence exchanged between the complainant and the Commission before the complaint, it was not clear whether the latter had indeed fulfilled this duty.

24. However, in its opinion, the Commission provided sufficient explanations to show that it did in fact supervise the Pillar's activities, and especially its expenditure, both ex ante (quarterly reports were a precondition to further payments) and ex post (by means of an independent audit which found no irregularity). Moreover, the Commission's explanations concerning its contacts with Pillar IV show that it communicated regularly with the pillar using different channels.

25. It thus appears that the Commission fulfilled all its formal verification obligations as regards the Pillar's use of the EU funds made available to it.

26. As regards the concrete issue of the retention bonus, the Ombudsman points out that neither the Financing Decision adopted by the Commission nor the subsequent contribution agreements established clear conditions for granting the bonus. This might have contributed to the complainant's view that the detailed rules laid down by the Pillar IV management actually contradicted the Decision.

27. On the other hand, however, the documents to which the Ombudsman's representatives had access during the inspection[13] made it clear that both the Commission and Pillar IV authorities considered that the latter had full discretion concerning this matter.

28. This view cannot be contested. The Ombudsman considers that, as long as the Commission fulfilled its objectives and respected the principles of EU law, it could validly refrain from establishing more concrete and detailed rules for awarding the bonus.

29. The bonus was to be granted in the context of very specific and exceptional circumstances, namely, the winding down of Pillar IV and the subsequent progressive transfer of its activities to the Kosovar authorities. As the Financing Decision points out, it was particularly difficult to maintain the necessary staff until the end of the Pillar IV mission. This could have jeopardised the pillar's achievement of its objectives. Moreover, from the documents to which the Ombudsman had access during the inspection of the Commission's files, it appears that the retention bonus was not meant as a general reward for all staff who remained in their posts until the end of Pillar IV's mission. The bonus only applied to key staff.

30. In the Ombudsman's view, it is not reasonable to claim that the Commission should have established more detailed criteria for the payment of the retention bonus. In any event, the Pillar IV management was the authority better placed to identify (i) the key positions that needed to be maintained until the end of the mission to ensure its objectives, (ii) the conditions that key personnel needed to fulfil in order to receive the bonus and (iii) when the payment of the retention bonus should be effected in order adequately to motivate such personnel to remain in service until the end of the mission. These decisions not only relate to staff policy, but also to complex technical and opportunity assessments in a particular political environment. They also require thorough knowledge of field conditions. All these elements were clearly available to the Pillar IV management and not to the Commission.

31. The Pillar IV management could thus legitimately use the discretion granted to it as regards the retention bonus in order to achieve the goal established by the Financing Decision and envisaged by the Commission.

32. In addition, nothing in the documents inspected suggests, as the complainant argues, that the Commission should have considered that funds were used for other purposes, in breach of the Financing Decision.

33. Finally, the Ombudsman notes that the Commission apparently made its own assessment of whether the rules concerning the retention bonus adopted by Pillar IV complied with EU principles in the complainant's case. Although the Commission (i) could not intervene in the decisions taken by Pillar IV or modify them once adopted, and (ii) was exempted from liability for contractual issues between Pillar IV and its contractors (as the Commission stated in its opinion and the inspected documents demonstrated), it still contacted the Pillar IV management regarding the concerns raised by the complainant. The Commission concluded that Pillar IV management followed the correct internal procedures and sought appropriate legal advice regarding the complainant's case.

34. During the inspection of the Commission's files, the Ombudsman's representatives could verify that the correspondence between the Commission and Pillar IV supports the Commission's above conclusion.

35. The Ombudsman considers that, whatever the degree of discretion left to the Commission's partners in the framework of a financing relationship, it would be good practice for the Commission to contact these partners in order to verify the individual circumstances of the case reported to it and thus ensure that EU principles, such as, for instance, the principles of transparency, equal treatment and non-discrimination, are fully respected.[14] The Commission did so in the present case. The Ombudsman therefore finds no instance of maladministration in this respect.

36. However, the Ombudsman points out that the employees of Pillar IV were unlikely to know that the Commission was not liable for potential damages arising from their contractual relationship with the Pillar[15]. From the complainant's observations, the Ombudsman concludes that, in situations in which the Commission appears prima facie to be very much involved, third parties may believe that they are in an indirect contractual relationship with the EU and thus under its protection. This belief, although contractually unfounded, is proof of the high esteem and confidence inspired by the EU, particularly in third countries. In order to avoid breaching that confidence, the Commission could consider requesting its partners to inform their own contractors that the Commission is not a party to their contract. In this respect, the Ombudsman will make a further remark below.

B. Conclusions

On the basis of his inquiry into this complaint, the Ombudsman closes it with the following conclusion:

The Ombudsman has not found an instance of maladministration by the Commission in this case.

The complainant and the Commission will be informed of this decision.

Further remark

In order to avoid false impressions concerning the nature and extent of its involvement in situations like the one described by the complainant, the Commission could consider requesting its partners to mention clearly, in their contacts with third parties, that it is not a party thereto and cannot be held responsible for contractual shortcomings.

 

P. Nikiforos Diamandouros

Done in Strasbourg on 2 September 2011


[1] Available at: http://www.nato.int/kosovo/docu/u990610a.htm

[2] Pillar IV was made up of several components: the Central Bank Authority, the UNMIK Customs Service, the Fiscal Affairs Service and the Kosovo Trust Agency.

[3] Council Regulation (EC) No 1080/2000 of 22 May 2000 on the support for the United Nations Interim Mission in Kosovo and the Office of the High Representative in Bosnia and Herzegovina. OJ 2000 L122, p. 27.

[4] Council Regulation (EC) No 1085/2006 of 17 July 2006 establishing an Instrument for Pre-Accession Assistance. OJ 2006 L210, p.82.

[5] Commission's Decision C(2007)2367 of 31 May 2007, concerning the financing of the Fourth Pillar from 1 June 2007 to 31 January 2008.

[6] In his decision on complaint 1256/2002/GG, the Ombudsman had already concluded that the Commission was not a party to employment contracts signed by UNMIK Pillar IV and its staff. Decision available at: http://www.ombudsman.europa.eu/cases/decision.faces/en/1761/html.bookmark

[7] Contribution Agreement 140/946 of 3 July 2007, amended on 19 September and 31 October 2007.

[8] Namely, biannual reports to the Commission and the European Parliament.

[9] As established in Article 1(5) of the Special Conditions of the Contribution Agreement.

[10] Article 1(3)(3) of the General and Administrative Provisions of the Contribution Agreement.

[11] Article 3 of the Contribution Agreement.

[12] Article 6 of the General Conditions of the Contribution Agreement, according to which the Pillar was obliged to publicise that it was funded by the EU. This included using the EU logo on its office material and other equipment.

[13] These documents were classified by the Commission as confidential. Therefore, pursuant to the Ombudsman's Implementing Provisions, neither the public nor the complainant can have access to them.

[14] By analogy, Article 43(6) of the Implementing Rules applicable to EU Financial Regulation, which provides that ”In the implementation of projects in joint management, international organisations shall comply with at least the following requirements: (a) procurement and grant award procedures shall comply with the principles of transparency, proportionality, sound financial management, equal treatment and non-discrimination, lack of conflict of interests and respect of internationally accepted standards.” Available at http://ec.europa.eu/budget/library/biblio/documents/regulations/syn_pub_rf_modex_en.pdf

[15] This is precisely the case in the current complaint and also in complaint 1256/2002/GG.