FOR PREVIEWING & TESTING PURPOSES ONLY.
This notification will disappear once the page will be published.
This link is available for less than 30 minutes.
  • Letlæselig
  • Tekststørrelse

Har du en klage over en EU-institution eller et EU-organ?

Nuværende sprog: 
  • English
Tilgængelige sprog: 
Oversættelsen af denne side vil være tilgængelig om få minutter. Du får besked, så snart den er klar. Bemærk, at på grund af stor belastning af eTranslation-værktøjet kan dette tage længere tid end normalt

Decision of the European Ombudsman closing his inquiry into complaint 296/2009/OV against the Council of the European Union

THE BACKGROUND TO THE COMPLAINT

1. The complainant is a client of the Belgian branch ("Kaupthing Belgium") of Kaupthing Bank Luxembourg. As a result of the financial crisis in autumn 2008, her savings accounts were blocked as from 9 October 2008.

2. On 7 October 2008, during an Ecofin meeting, the Council discussed the financial crisis and the necessary measures to deal with it. It adopted what it referred to as "Immediate responses to financial turmoil". The Council's conclusions were worded as follows:

"In the current troubled situation in the financial sector, ..., we agree that the priority is to restore confidence and proper functioning of the financial sector.

We have agreed to support systemic financial institutions. We all commit to take all necessary measures to enhance the soundness and stability of our banking system and to protect the deposits of individual savers ....

Several Member States have recently increased the level of coverage of national deposit guarantee schemes. We agreed that all Member States would, for an initial period of at least one year, provide deposit guarantee protection for individuals for an amount of at least EUR 50 000, acknowledging that many Member States determine to raise their minimum to EUR 100 000. We welcome the intention of the Commission to bring forward urgently an appropriate proposal to promote convergence of deposit guarantee schemes ...".

3. On 7 January 2009, the complainant submitted to the Council what she referred to as a "complaint against the Council for failure to stand by its word and the infringement of the principle of legitimate expectations." In her complaint, she stated that, on 24 November 2008, she submitted a complaint against the Luxembourg authorities to Commissioner Kroes. She went on to quote part of the Commission's reply of 23 December 2008, which concerned the decision taken at the Ecofin Council meeting of 7 October 2008 regarding the increase in the guaranteed minimum amount of savings from EUR 20 000 to EUR 50 000. In its reply, the Commission took the view that the relevant statement was a political declaration which was not legally binding. It then explained that it had adopted a proposal for an amendment of Directive 94/19/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 30 May 2004 on the deposit guarantee schemes[1]. This proposal envisaged a retroactive increase, as from 15 October 2008, in the guaranteed minimum amount of protected savings from EUR 20 000 to EUR 50 000. The Commission added that, following negotiations, it concluded that the increase in the proposed coverage had to be implemented by 30 June 2009. In her complaint to the Council, the complainant pointed out that the Ecofin Council defined its declarations of 7 October 2008 as "Immediate responses to the financial turmoil" and that these declarations aimed at reassuring savers. The complainant further submitted that these declarations were not conditional, and their applicability was not subject to a specific time frame. Given that the Council had, in her view, subsequently distanced itself from its declarations, the complainant argued that the Council was guilty of "deceiving the European citizens". She alleged that, by not respecting the commitments entered into on 7 October 2008, the Council infringed the principle of legitimate expectations.

4. In its reply of 22 January 2009, the Council pointed out that Article 7(1) of Directive 94/19/EC foresees that Member States have to guarantee savings accounts for an amount of at least EUR 20 000. The Council then referred to the Ecofin meeting of 7 October 2008, which concluded that a whole series of measures were necessary in order to improve citizens' trust in the banking sector. More specifically, the Council stated that, in its conclusions, which were not legally binding, it defined general guidelines for a Directive proposal aimed at reinforcing the rules on the guarantee of deposits. It further stated that the Commission had thereupon presented a proposal for an amendment of Directive 94/19/EC, which foresaw an initial increase in the minimum guarantee to EUR 50 000, and a further increase to EUR 100 000 after a year. The Council explained that this proposal was governed by the co-decision procedure and that the Directive resulting from it should be adopted in the first semester of 2009. It concluded by stating that if the complainant felt that the Council had committed maladministration in relation to this matter, she could complain to the European Ombudsman ("si vous estimez que le Conseil ... a commis, par rapport à ce dossier, un cas de mauvaise administration, vous pouvez déposer plainte auprès du médiateur européen ...").

THE SUBJECT MATTER OF THE INQUIRY

5. In her complaint to the Ombudsman, the complainant made the following two allegations:

  1. The Council, by failing to do what it announced at the Ecofin meeting of 7 October 2008 in so far as the protection of savings held by banks in the EU is concerned, failed to stand by its word, deceived European citizens and infringed the principle of legitimate expectations.
  2. By distinguishing between two categories of financial institutions (systemic and non-systemic), the Council's conclusions of 7 October 2008 implied a distortion of competition.

6. In his letter of 27 February 2009 opening the present inquiry, the Ombudsman asked the Council to submit an opinion on the first allegation. Given that the complainant had not made appropriate prior administrative approaches to the Council with regard to the second allegation, the Ombudsman concluded that it was inadmissible and informed the complainant and the Council accordingly. On 9 April 2009, the complainant wrote again to the Ombudsman. She informed him that she had in the meantime raised her second allegation with the Council, which had replied on 2 April 2009. She therefore suggested that the Ombudsman should include her second allegation in his inquiry. On 19 May 2009, the Ombudsman replied to the complainant informing her that he considered it preferable to wait for the Council's opinion, and her observations on it, before deciding on how to deal with her second allegation.

7. After examining the Council's opinion and the complainant's observations on it, the Ombudsman concluded that the second allegation did not concern possible maladministration. It was directed at the substance of the conclusions of the Ecofin meeting of 7 October 2008, which are of a political nature and therefore not within his mandate. By letters of 22 October 2009, the Ombudsman informed the complainant and the Council that he would not include the second allegation in his inquiry. Given that the second allegation is outside the Ombudsman's mandate, the present inquiry only concerns the complainant's first allegation.

THE INQUIRY

8. The complaint was forwarded to the Council for an opinion. The Council sent its opinion on 19 June 2009. The opinion was forwarded to the complainant, whose observations were received by the Ombudsman's office on 6 July 2009.

9. In its opinion, the Council took the view that the complaint was outside of the Ombudsman's mandate. On 22 October 2009, the Ombudsman informed the Council that he agreed with its view, given that the conclusions reached at the Ecofin meeting of 7 October 2008 were of a political nature. However, he underlined that, in her first allegation, the complainant did not challenge these conclusions as such, but alleged that the Council committed maladministration by failing to implement them, and thereby failed to stand by its word, deceived European citizens and infringed the principle of legitimate expectations. The Ombudsman considered that these issues were within his mandate. He therefore reiterated his request to the Council for an opinion on the substance of the complainant's first allegation.

10. On 5 November 2009, the Council sent its additional opinion on the first allegation. It was then forwarded to the complainant, who sent her observations on 27 November 2009.

THE OMBUDSMAN'S ANALYSIS AND CONCLUSIONS

A. Alleged failure to follow-up the declarations made at the Ecofin meeting of 7 October 2008

Arguments presented to the Ombudsman

11. The complainant alleged that the Council failed to do what it had announced at its Ecofin meeting of 7 October 2008 regarding the protection of savings held by banks in the EU. It thereby failed to stand by its word, deceived European citizens and infringed the principle of legitimate expectations.

12. In its first opinion, the Council argued that the complainant's first allegation was inadmissible. The Council recalled the wording of Article 195 of the EC Treaty (now Article 228 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union) and stated that the Ombudsman's mandate was limited to the activities of the institutions in their administrative capacity. It argued that the political and legislative activity of the Council cannot give rise to a case of maladministration and is thus outside of the Ombudsman's mandate.

13. In her observations, the complainant rejected the Council's viewpoint and argued that, if the acts of the institutions could never be considered as of an administrative nature, they would never be subject to mediation in the exercise of their essential functions.

14. On 22 October 2009, the Ombudsman informed the Council of his view that the first allegation was within his mandate. He also reiterated his request for an opinion on the substance of that allegation. In its second opinion, the Council maintained its position that the complaint was outside of the Ombudsman's mandate. It pointed out that the Ombudsman had agreed that the conclusions reached at the Ecofin meeting of 7 October 2008 were of a political nature. Moreover, it argued that these conclusions: (i) reflected that the Council had taken a political position in favour of the increase in the deposit guarantees of individuals; and (ii) provided that the necessary implementation measures would be taken in conformity with the rules foreseen in the Treaties, namely, on the basis of a Commission proposal. The Council therefore did not share the Ombudsman's view that the alleged non-respect of the commitments outlined in the Ecofin conclusions fell within its administrative activity. It went on to highlight that the implementation of these conclusions required the adoption of a legislative act that would modify Directive 94/19/EC in order to increase the level of minimum deposit guarantee protection to EUR 50 000. Given these circumstances, allowing the Ombudsman to deal with the complainant's case would implicitly enable him to exercise control over: (i) the Council's function as legislator when it receives a Commission proposal; and (ii) the Commission's power of initiative.

15. In her observations, the complainant accepted that the Council's decisions themselves fell within its political activity, but argued that the method and the terms used to communicate them to the citizens fell within its administrative activity. She stated that, to understand her complaint, one had to take into account the historical context of the press conference that followed the Council meeting of 7 October 2008. Considering that the Ecofin Council qualified its conclusions as "Immediate responses to financial turmoil", it was clear that their aim was to reassure savers to avoid them rushing to withdraw their savings from banks across the EU. As a result of this press conference, certain savers left their savings with non-systemic banks like Kaupthing Bank Luxembourg. Certain savers even increased their deposits with the latter bank, which used the Council's declarations for marketing purposes. Given that the savers concerned suffered no losses, the complainant underlined that her complaint was purely symbolic and made in the citizens' interest.

The Ombudsman's assessment

16. In his letter to the Council of 22 October 2009, the Ombudsman confirmed that the conclusions reached at the Ecofin meeting of 7 October 2008 were of a political nature and, therefore, outside of his mandate. This is why the complainant's second allegation, which concerned the substance of these conclusions, was outside his mandate.

17. The complainant's first allegation did not, however, concern the substance of the conclusions reached at the Ecofin meeting as such. It rather stated that, by failing to do what it had announced at that meeting, the Council failed to stand by its word, deceived European citizens and infringed the principle of legitimate expectations. The complainant's first allegation thus concerned the implementation of the Council's Ecofin conclusions.

18. The commitments which, in the complainant's view, the Council entered into at its Ecofin meeting can be summarised as follows: (i) deposit guarantee protection would be provided to individuals for an amount of at least EUR 50 000; (ii) this would apply for all Member States; (iii) the protection would be guaranteed for an initial period of at least one year; and (iv) the protection would be granted immediately.

19. The position adopted by the Council at the Ecofin meeting of 7 October 2008 clearly constitutes a political choice. The Ombudsman is unable to deal with complaints against a political choice as such, for instance a complaint alleging that the amount of EUR 50 000 proposed by the Council was inadequate.

20. However, the complainant's first allegation does not concern the political decision as such, but rather the question whether the Council failed to implement the said decision and, by doing so, failed to stand by its word, deceived citizens and infringed the principle of legitimate expectations. The Ombudsman remains of the opinion that these are issues which, as a matter of principle, he can investigate. It is obvious, however, that such a complaint can only be well-founded if the Council had indeed entered into precise commitments and then failed to comply with them.

21. The Council argued that accepting the Ombudsman's mandate in a case like the present would implicitly enable him to exercise control over: (i) its function as legislator when it receives a Commission proposal; and (ii) the Commission's power of initiative. The Ombudsman considers that none of these arguments are well-founded. It should first be pointed out that the present inquiry concerns the Council and not the Commission. In addition, the statements contained in the conclusions of the Ecofin meeting of 7 October 2008 were made before any Commission proposal[2] had been submitted to the Council. The decision thus taken was therefore the Council's, and only the Council's. The only issue which the Ombudsman is able to examine is therefore whether the Council subsequently complied with the specific commitments it had - in the complainant's view - entered into on 7 October 2008.

22. In its letter of 22 January 2009, the Council informed the complainant that, if she felt that the Council had committed maladministration in relation to this matter, she could complain to the European Ombudsman. If the Ombudsman has indeed no competence whatsoever in this field, as the Council now argues, then the advice given by the Council in its letter of 22 January 2009 would have been incorrect and misleading. The Ombudsman considers that it should not be assumed that a Union institution would intentionally provide citizens with incorrect and misleading advice.

23. The subsequent amendment of Directive 94/19/EC through Directive 2009/14/EC[3] introduced EU-wide deposit guarantee protection amounting to at least EUR 50 000. This protection had to be provided by Member States by 30 June 2009 (Article 2(1) of Directive 2009/14/EC) and would continue for an undefined period of time. The above legislation implements the relevant conclusions of the Ecofin meeting of 7 October 2008. The only exception is that the change in deposit guarantee protection was not introduced as from 7 October 2008, but rather 30 June 2009. Persons holding saving accounts in Member States where the coverage level was lower than EUR 50 000 prior to 1 July 2009 therefore risked losing money if their banks had become insolvent between October 2008 and the end of June 2009.

24. In its proposal for what ultimately became Directive 2009/14/EC, the Commission justified the proposed retroactive increase in the level of protection by referring to, among other things, the "legitimate expectations of all parties concerned". It thus seems that the Commission considered that point (iv) of the conclusions (see paragraph 18 above) could give rise to such legitimate expectations.

25. The Council appears to submit in its opinions that the conclusions informed the public that the European Union would take legislative action with a view to strengthening the protection of savers. Given that legislation in the field concerned can only be adopted on the basis of a proposal made by the Commission, and that the Council does not decide on such proposals alone, but together with the European Parliament, such an interpretation would make sense. However, the fact that the measures set out in the conclusions would still need to be enshrined in Union legislation does not emerge from these conclusions as clearly as one would expect in such a case. The language used there ("We agree...") suggests that a decision on the substance had already been taken and that the protection described in the conclusions would be granted by Member States, if only "for an initial period of one year".

26. Regard should, however, be had to the fact that the issue has become devoid of relevance, given that savers do not appear to have suffered any losses prior to 1 July 2009. The complainant herself has stated that her complaint has become of academic interest only and that her action was symbolic. The Ombudsman therefore considers that there are no grounds for further inquiries into the present complaint.

B. Conclusions

On the basis of his inquiry into this complaint, the Ombudsman closes it with the following conclusion:

There are no grounds for further inquiries into the present complaint.

The complainant and the Council will be informed of this decision.

 

P. Nikiforos DIAMANDOUROS

Done in Strasbourg on 5 March 2010


[1] OJ 1994 L 135, p. 5.

[2] The Commission's proposal was adopted on 15 October 2008, one week after the Ecofin meeting of 7 October 2008.

[3] Directive 2009/14/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 11 March 2009 amending Directive 94/19/EC on deposit-guarantee schemes as regards the coverage level and the payout delay, OJ 2009, L 68, p. 4.